Hunter W Stuart, Baumrind Sheldon, Popovich Frank, Jorgensen Gertrud
University of Western Ontario, London, Ontario, Canada.
Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop. 2007 Mar;131(3):327-33. doi: 10.1016/j.ajodo.2006.09.036.
It is generally believed that the orthodontic treatment of a patient with a Class II malocclusion and a small mandible is enhanced by good growth at puberty, so that the timing of peak mandibular growth at puberty becomes of interest.
To test the belief that skeletal age, whether early, average, or late, can be used to predict the timing of maximum growth of the mandible, whether early, average, or late, the predictive relationship between skeletal age and peak mandibular growth velocity (PMdV) at puberty was evaluated in 94 boys by using their longitudinal records from 4 to 18 years of age. Skeletal age was determined for each subject at ages 9 through 14 by using the method of Greulich and Pyle.
At age 9, the Greulich and Pyle measurements predicted that 30 of the 94 subjects would have delayed PMdV equal to or exceeding 1 SD (of the mean age for PMdV), and 10 would have advanced PMdV equal to or exceeding 1 SD. When the actual age of PMdV was determined retrospectively from plots of annual mandibular growth increments, it was found that only 4 of the 30 in the delayed group had actually experienced delays in PMdV, and only 2 of the 10 in the advanced group had experienced accelerated PMdV.
Skeletal age is not a reliable predictor of the timing of PMdV.
人们普遍认为,青春期良好的生长发育有助于改善Ⅱ类错颌畸形和小下颌患者的正畸治疗效果,因此青春期下颌生长高峰的时间备受关注。
为了验证骨骼年龄(无论是早、平均还是晚)能否用于预测下颌最大生长时间(无论是早、平均还是晚)这一观点,我们利用94名男孩从4岁到18岁的纵向记录,评估了骨骼年龄与青春期下颌生长高峰速度(PMdV)之间的预测关系。采用格雷利希和派尔方法确定了每位受试者9至14岁时的骨骼年龄。
9岁时,格雷利希和派尔测量结果预测,94名受试者中有30人下颌生长高峰速度延迟,等于或超过1个标准差(下颌生长高峰速度的平均年龄标准差),10人下颌生长高峰速度提前,等于或超过1个标准差。当通过每年下颌生长增量图回顾性确定下颌生长高峰速度的实际年龄时,发现延迟组的30人中只有4人实际经历了下颌生长高峰速度延迟,提前组的10人中只有2人经历了下颌生长高峰速度加快。
骨骼年龄不是下颌生长高峰速度时间的可靠预测指标。