Cameron Jacqui, Ritter Alison
Turning Point Alcohol and Drug Centre, Fitzroy, VIC, Australia.
Drug Alcohol Rev. 2007 Mar;26(2):183-9. doi: 10.1080/09595230601184653.
Given the very positive and extensive research evidence demonstrating efficacy and effectiveness of contingency management, it is important that Australia explore whether contingency management has a role to play in our own treatment context. Qualitative interviews were conducted with 30 experienced alcohol and drug practitioners, service managers and policy-makers in Victoria. Interviewees were selected to represent the range of drug treatment services types and included rural representation. A semi-structured interview schedule, covering their perceptions and practices of contingency management was used. All interviews were transcribed verbatim and analysed using N2 qualitative data analysis program. The majority of key informants were positively inclined toward contingency management, notwithstanding some concerns about the philosophical underpinnings. Concerns were raised in relation to the use of monetary rewards. Examples of the use of contingency management provided by key informants demonstrated an over-inclusive definition: all the examples did not adhere to the key principles of contingency management. This may create problems if a structured contingency management were to be introduced in Australia. Contingency management is an important adjunctive treatment intervention and its use in Australia has the potential to enhance treatment outcomes. No unmanageable barriers were identified in this study.
鉴于有非常积极且广泛的研究证据表明应急管理的有效性,澳大利亚探索应急管理在本国治疗环境中能否发挥作用就显得很重要。我们对维多利亚州30名经验丰富的酒精和药物治疗从业者、服务经理及政策制定者进行了定性访谈。受访者的选取旨在代表各类药物治疗服务类型,其中包括来自农村地区的受访者。我们采用了一份涵盖他们对应急管理的看法和实践的半结构化访谈提纲。所有访谈都逐字记录,并使用N2定性数据分析程序进行分析。尽管对其哲学基础存在一些担忧,但大多数关键信息提供者对应急管理持积极态度。有人对金钱奖励的使用提出了担忧。关键信息提供者提供的应急管理使用示例展示了一个过于宽泛的定义:所有示例均未遵循应急管理的关键原则。如果在澳大利亚引入结构化的应急管理,这可能会产生问题。应急管理是一种重要的辅助治疗干预措施,在澳大利亚使用它有提高治疗效果的潜力。本研究未发现无法解决的障碍。