Ryaboshapko Alexey, Bullock O Russell, Christensen Jesper, Cohen Mark, Dastoor Ashu, Ilyin Ilia, Petersen Gerhard, Syrakov Dimiter, Travnikov Oleg, Artz Richard S, Davignon Didier, Draxler Roland R, Munthe John, Pacyna Jozef
Meteorological Synthesizing Center-East of EMEP, Leningradsky Pr., 16-2, Moscow 125040, Russia.
Sci Total Environ. 2007 May 15;377(2-3):319-33. doi: 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2007.01.071. Epub 2007 Mar 23.
Five regional scale models with a horizontal domain covering the European continent and its surrounding seas, two hemispheric and one global scale model participated in the atmospheric Hg modelling intercomparison study. The models were compared between each other and with available measurements from 11 monitoring stations of the EMEP measurement network. Because only a very limited number of long-term measurement records of Hg were available, significant attention was given to the intercomparison of modelling results. Monthly and annually averaged values of Hg concentrations and depositions as well as items of the Hg deposition budgets for individual European countries were compared. The models demonstrated good agreement (within +/-20%) between annual modelled and observed values of gaseous elemental Hg. Modelled values of Hg wet deposition in Western and Central Europe agreed with the observations within +/-45%. The probability to predict wet depositions within a factor of 2 with regard to measurements was 50-70% for all the models. The scattering of modelling results for dry depositions of Hg was more significant (up to +/-50% at the annual scale and even higher for monthly data). Contribution of dry deposition to the total Hg deposition was estimated at 20-30% with elevated dry deposition fluxes during summer time. The participating models agree in their predictions of transboundary pollution for individual countries within +/-60% at the monthly scale and within +/-30% at the annual scale. For the cases investigated, all the models predict that the major part of national anthropogenic Hg emissions is transported outside the country territory.
五个水平域覆盖欧洲大陆及其周边海域的区域尺度模型、两个半球尺度模型和一个全球尺度模型参与了大气汞建模比对研究。这些模型相互之间进行了比较,并与欧洲监测和评价计划(EMEP)测量网络11个监测站的现有测量数据进行了比较。由于汞的长期测量记录数量非常有限,因此对建模结果的比对给予了高度关注。比较了汞浓度和沉降的月均值和年均值,以及欧洲各国汞沉降预算的各项内容。模型显示,气态单质汞的年度模拟值与观测值之间具有良好的一致性(在±20%以内)。西欧和中欧汞湿沉降的模拟值与观测值在±45%以内相符。所有模型预测湿沉降与测量值相差不超过2倍的概率为50%-70%。汞干沉降建模结果的离散度更大(在年尺度上高达±50%,月数据的离散度更高)。夏季干沉降通量升高,干沉降对汞总沉降的贡献估计为20%-30%。参与的模型在月尺度上对各国跨界污染的预测一致性在±60%以内,年尺度上在±30%以内。对于所研究的案例,所有模型都预测各国人为汞排放的主要部分被输送到该国领土之外。