Lillehagen M, Grindefjord M, Mejàre I
Department of Paediatric Dentistry, Eastman Dental Institute, Stockholm, Sweden.
Caries Res. 2007;41(3):177-85. doi: 10.1159/000099315.
The aims were to determine caries prevalence in 9-year-olds belonging to a low-caries prevalence population and to assess how accurately some commonly used risk factors/risk markers (predictors) can identify additional approximal caries as judged from bitewing examination (BW). One calibrated dentist examined 117 consecutive 9-year-olds from the inner city of Stockholm. The predictors were the number of clinically detected dfs and DFS, visible plaque, salivary mutans streptococci, tooth brushing habits, consumption of sugary products, parents' education, and (before BW) an overall clinical judgement by the examiner. Analyses of the data included sensitivity and specificity and a multiple logistic regression model. When BW was included, the mean DFS was 0.27 and the mean dfs 1.74. For approximal enamel and dentin lesions, the average gain from BW was 0.20 lesions for permanent first molars and 1.23 lesions for primary molars. Altogether, 48% of the children benefited from BW. The best predictors of additional approximal caries from BW were presence of caries (cavitation/dentin level) on occlusal surfaces of permanent first molars and the dentist's judgement based on clinical findings, both with a combined sensitivity and specificity of 134%. The only statistically significant variables in a logistic regression model were the dentist's judgement and the child's statement about regular tooth brushing. It is concluded that a sizeable proportion of 9-year-olds, representing a low-caries prevalence population, benefited from BW. However, the ability to identify these children from the predictors was limited.
目的是确定属于低龋患率人群的9岁儿童的龋病患病率,并评估一些常用的风险因素/风险标志物(预测指标)根据咬合翼片检查(BW)判断额外邻面龋的识别准确性。一位经过校准的牙医检查了来自斯德哥尔摩市中心的117名连续的9岁儿童。预测指标包括临床检测到的dfs和DFS数量、可见菌斑、唾液变形链球菌、刷牙习惯、含糖产品的摄入量、父母的教育程度,以及(在BW检查之前)检查者的总体临床判断。数据分析包括敏感性和特异性以及多元逻辑回归模型。纳入BW检查后,平均DFS为0.27,平均dfs为1.74。对于邻面釉质和牙本质病变,BW检查对恒牙第一磨牙平均增加0.20个病变,对乳牙磨牙平均增加1.23个病变。总体而言,48%的儿童从BW检查中受益。BW检查额外邻面龋的最佳预测指标是恒牙第一磨牙咬合面龋(龋洞/牙本质深度)的存在以及基于临床检查结果的牙医判断,两者的综合敏感性和特异性为134%。逻辑回归模型中唯一具有统计学意义的变量是牙医的判断和儿童关于定期刷牙的陈述。结论是,相当比例的9岁儿童(代表低龋患率人群)从BW检查中受益。然而,通过预测指标识别这些儿童的能力有限。