Havet Eric, Gabrion Antoine, Leiber-Wackenheim Frederic, Vernois Joël, Olory Bruno, Mertl Patrice
Department of Anatomy, Medical University, 3 rue des Louvels, 80000 Amiens, France.
Surg Radiol Anat. 2007 Jun;29(4):285-9. doi: 10.1007/s00276-007-0207-3. Epub 2007 Apr 18.
Restoring the joint line level is one of the surgical challenges during revision of total knee arthroplasty. The position of the tibial surface is commonly estimated by its distance to the apex of fibular head, but no study evaluating this distance accurately has been published yet. The purpose of this work was to study the distance between the knee joint line and the apex of the fibular head and the proximal tibia, particularly the tibial tuberosity. Variability with clinical data and relations with other local measurements have been evaluated on knee radiographs (an antero-posterior view, a medio-lateral view and an anteroposterior full length view) of 100 subjects (125 knees). Results showed no correlation between the joint line-fibular head apex distance and any clinical data of the patients, or any other performed measurements. Relations between tibial measurements and the sexe or the height of the subjects were noted. Besides, the review of the 25 bilateral cases did not show statistically significant side difference but the descriptive analysis showed too large discrepancies for the joint line-fibular head apex distance to be used as a landmark. We conclude that the fibular head apex cannot be used as a morphologic landmark to determine the knee joint line position. Its interest in clinical and surgical practice must be discussed.
恢复关节线水平是全膝关节置换翻修手术中的一项挑战。胫骨表面的位置通常通过其与腓骨头顶点的距离来估计,但尚未有研究对该距离进行准确评估。本研究的目的是探讨膝关节线与腓骨头顶点以及胫骨近端(特别是胫骨结节)之间的距离。我们在100名受试者(125个膝关节)的膝关节X线片(前后位、内外侧位和全长前后位)上评估了其与临床数据的变异性以及与其他局部测量值的关系。结果显示,关节线-腓骨头顶点距离与患者的任何临床数据或其他测量值之间均无相关性。我们注意到胫骨测量值与受试者的性别或身高之间存在关联。此外,对25例双侧病例的回顾显示,虽然差异无统计学意义,但描述性分析表明,关节线-腓骨头顶点距离的差异过大,无法用作定位标志。我们得出结论,腓骨头顶点不能用作确定膝关节线位置的形态学标志。必须讨论其在临床和手术实践中的意义。