Seldon H Lee
20 Lomond Drive, Glen Waverley, Vic. 3150, Australia.
Med Hypotheses. 2007;69(5):1085-9. doi: 10.1016/j.mehy.2007.03.001. Epub 2007 Apr 20.
I suggest that the extended maturation time of some regions of the human neocortex is the uniquely human factor which allows the development of language, creativity and madness. The genetic event or events which contribute to the long delay to final maturation occurred at or after the speciation of Homo sapiens sapiens. Neocortical growth may follow the previously detailed "balloon model", which suggests that intra- and subcortical myelin production during development physically stretches each local area of the cortex tangentially to the pial surface, thereby causing neuronal columns to become more disjoint and more functionally independent, thereby increasing the functional capacity of the area [Seldon HL. Does brain white matter growth expand the cortex like a balloon? Hypothesis and consequences. Laterality 2005;10(1):81-95]. This occurs in addition to Hebbian synaptic modeling. Therefore, the size and functional capacity of each cytoarchitectonic area of each individual adult neocortex are the outcomes of partly deterministic (e.g., genetic) and partly statistical growth processes with numerous factors including environmental stimuli and fatty acid content in diets. The possible functional capacity and variation among growth outcomes increase with the length of time allowed to "finalize" synaptic weights, myelination and other plastic processes. For example, acquisition of quite differing linguistic skills becomes possible only in Homo sapiens because of the extended, decades-long plasticity of temporal lobe areas; in contrast, tactile skills vary little among human races and cultures, or even among higher primates, because of the faster maturation of the somatomotor areas. Some of the statistically extreme variations of the neocortical growth processes lead to abnormal cognition and behavior called "madness" or "genius". This maturation hypothesis overcomes some problems with those based purely on fatty acid metabolism or on functional asymmetry (non-human species show functional asymmetry, but no language. Neanderthals had brains comparable in size and shape to ours, but failed to develop language or creativity). This hypothesis implies that the search for genetic factors should include those which influence the temporal regulation of neuronal and myelin growth, but it also allows the development of unusual creativity or madness as a statistical extreme in the absence of any deterministic factors. It has implications about our attitudes toward mental "disorders" and about potential approaches to treating some of them - for example, attempting communication and conditioning via those senses and cortical areas which show less variation and are less affected.
我认为人类新皮层某些区域延长的成熟时间是使得语言、创造力和疯狂得以发展的独特人类因素。导致最终成熟长期延迟的一个或多个基因事件发生在智人物种形成之时或之后。新皮层的生长可能遵循先前详细阐述的“气球模型”,该模型表明发育过程中皮层内和皮层下的髓鞘生成会在物理上沿着软脑膜表面切向拉伸皮层的每个局部区域,从而使神经元柱变得更加分散且功能更加独立,进而增加该区域的功能容量[Seldon HL. 脑白质生长是否像气球一样扩张皮层?假说及影响。《偏侧性》2005年;10(1):81 - 95]。这一过程在赫布式突触建模之外发生。因此,每个成年个体新皮层的每个细胞构筑区域的大小和功能容量是部分确定性(如基因)和部分统计性生长过程的结果,这些过程受到众多因素影响,包括环境刺激和饮食中的脂肪酸含量。随着允许“确定”突触权重、髓鞘形成和其他可塑性过程的时间长度增加,生长结果的可能功能容量和变异性也会增加。例如,由于颞叶区域长达数十年的可塑性延长,只有人类才有可能习得截然不同的语言技能;相比之下,由于躯体运动区域成熟较快,触觉技能在不同种族和文化之间,甚至在高等灵长类动物之间差异很小。新皮层生长过程中一些统计上的极端变异会导致被称为“疯狂”或“天才”的异常认知和行为。这一成熟假说克服了一些仅基于脂肪酸代谢或功能不对称的假说所存在的问题(非人类物种表现出功能不对称,但没有语言。尼安德特人的大脑在大小和形状上与我们的相当,但未能发展出语言或创造力)。该假说意味着对遗传因素的寻找应包括那些影响神经元和髓鞘生长时间调节的因素,但它也允许在没有任何确定性因素的情况下,将异常创造力或疯狂发展为一种统计上的极端情况。它对我们对待精神“障碍”的态度以及治疗其中一些障碍的潜在方法具有启示意义——例如,尝试通过那些变异较小且受影响较小的感官和皮层区域进行交流和调节。