Schulman K A, Glick H A, Rubin H, Eisenberg J M
Department of Medicine, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia.
JAMA. 1991 Dec 25;266(24):3466-71.
To assess the cost-effectiveness of the HA-1A monoclonal antibody for the treatment of gram-negative bacteremia.
Cost-effectiveness analysis of a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial using clinical efficacy data reported in the medical literature.
Hospitalized patients with sepsis.
543 patients with sepsis and suspected gram-negative infection. Patients enrolled in the study met strict criteria for sepsis, including fever or hypothermia (less than 35.6 degrees C or greater than 38.3 degrees C), tachycardia (greater than 90 beats per minute), tachypnea (greater than 20 breaths per minute), and hypotension or two of six signs of systemic toxicity.
HA-1A vs placebo in addition to usual care.
We determined the range of possible cost-effectiveness ratios for HA-1A therapy, using modeling techniques when clinical or economic variables were unknown. We subjected the model to rigorous sensitivity analysis. We calculated the incremental cost of care and years of life saved for patients with sepsis and modeled two different treatment strategies: treat all patients with sepsis or test and then treat only patients with positive test results. $24,100 per year of life saved based on the treat strategy and $14,900 based on the test strategy. In sensitivity analysis the ratios ranged from $5200 to $110,200 per year of life gained. Annual costs of care for these two strategies are $1.3 billion for the test strategy and $2.3 billion for the treat strategy.
Economic assessment of new technologies early in their development can be used to guide their efficient clinical introduction.
评估HA-1A单克隆抗体治疗革兰氏阴性菌血症的成本效益。
利用医学文献中报道的临床疗效数据,对一项随机、双盲、安慰剂对照试验进行成本效益分析。
脓毒症住院患者。
543例脓毒症且怀疑革兰氏阴性菌感染的患者。纳入该研究的患者符合严格的脓毒症标准,包括发热或体温过低(低于35.6摄氏度或高于38.3摄氏度)、心动过速(每分钟超过90次心跳)、呼吸急促(每分钟超过20次呼吸)以及低血压或六项全身毒性体征中的两项。
除常规治疗外,使用HA-1A或安慰剂。
当临床或经济变量未知时,我们采用建模技术确定了HA-1A治疗可能的成本效益比范围。我们对该模型进行了严格的敏感性分析。我们计算了脓毒症患者护理的增量成本和挽救的生命年数,并对两种不同的治疗策略进行了建模:治疗所有脓毒症患者或先检测,然后仅治疗检测结果呈阳性的患者。基于治疗策略,每挽救一年生命的成本为24,100美元,基于检测策略为14,900美元。在敏感性分析中,每获得一年生命的比率范围为5200美元至110,200美元。这两种策略的年度护理成本,检测策略为13亿美元,治疗策略为23亿美元。
在新技术研发早期进行经济评估可用于指导其高效的临床应用。