Hills Rosemary, Kitchen Sheila
Clinical Specialist, Physiotherapy Department, Mile End Hospital, London, UK.
Physiother Theory Pract. 2007 Jan-Feb;23(1):1-20. doi: 10.1080/09593980601023705.
Patient satisfaction is generally regarded as an important component in quality health care. However, there has been little satisfaction research in physiotherapy compared with that in other clinical fields with few qualitative studies that have explored patients' perceptions and attitudes toward physiotherapy. We report on the use of focus groups, as part of a multimethod approach of qualitative data collection into patients' satisfaction with their outpatient physiotherapy within the NHS system of care in the United Kingdom. We explored the factors that affect patients' satisfaction with musculoskeletal outpatient physiotherapy. A purposeful sample of patients with acute and chronic musculoskeletal patients who had been discharged from physiotherapy within the previous 4 months was drawn from both an inner city and suburban hospital. Two acute groups (n = 4, n = 10) and two chronic groups (n = 5, n = 11) were convened. A topic guide drew on themes that had emerged from the earlier qualitative phases of the study and guided the discussion in relation to pretreatment, treatment, and outcome stages of physiotherapy care. Sessions were tape-recorded, transcribed, and content was analyzed to code and categorise the primary patterns in the data. Although subjects in both the acute and chronic groups expected that treatment would improve their symptoms and function, they differed in the degree to which they perceived that this was achieved. Both satisfactory and unsatisfactory aspects of care emerged under the principal themes of expectations, communication, perceptions of the therapist, treatment process, and outcome. Those in the acute group were optimistic of a good result, whereas those with chronic degenerative conditions were either doubtful of improvement or unrealistic in their hopes for complete resolution of their symptoms. It was also apparent that subjects could be further divided into one of three groups (positive, negative, ambivalent), depending on the degree to which they perceived their needs and expectations had been met. Verbatim comments are presented to illustrate the spectrum of views expressed. The therapeutic encounter between therapist and patient is complex and reflects the multidimensional construct of satisfaction. Focus groups were used in this study as part of a multimethod approach into patient satisfaction with outpatient physiotherapy; they provided additional valuable insight into the reasoning process behind patients' evaluation of their care. Establishing patients' needs, particularly the extent to which these might be psychosocial rather than physical, could point the way to a more patient-focussed and productive physiotherapy experience. Although rich in-depth information was obtained from this study, caution should be applied in generalizing the findings because of the small sample sizes and the setting of the study within the NHS system of care. Therefore, further work to identify the full spectrum of issues relating to patients' satisfaction with their outpatient care is indicated.
患者满意度通常被视为优质医疗保健的一个重要组成部分。然而,与其他临床领域相比,物理治疗方面的满意度研究较少,定性研究也很少,这些研究探讨了患者对物理治疗的看法和态度。我们报告了焦点小组的使用情况,这是在英国国民保健服务体系中对患者门诊物理治疗满意度进行定性数据收集的多方法途径的一部分。我们探讨了影响患者对肌肉骨骼门诊物理治疗满意度的因素。从市中心医院和郊区医院抽取了有目的的样本,这些患者是急性和慢性肌肉骨骼疾病患者,在过去4个月内已从物理治疗中出院。召集了两个急性组(n = 4,n = 10)和两个慢性组(n = 5,n = 11)。一个主题指南借鉴了该研究早期定性阶段出现的主题,并指导了关于物理治疗护理的预处理、治疗和结果阶段的讨论。会议进行了录音、转录,并对内容进行了分析,以对数据中的主要模式进行编码和分类。尽管急性组和慢性组的受试者都期望治疗能改善他们的症状和功能,但他们在认为这一目标实现的程度上存在差异。在期望、沟通、对治疗师的看法、治疗过程和结果等主要主题下,出现了护理的满意和不满意方面。急性组的人对取得好结果持乐观态度,而患有慢性退行性疾病的人要么对改善表示怀疑,要么对症状完全缓解的希望不切实际。同样明显的是,根据受试者认为其需求和期望得到满足的程度,他们可以进一步分为三组之一(积极、消极、矛盾)。给出了逐字评论以说明所表达观点的范围。治疗师与患者之间的治疗互动很复杂,反映了满意度的多维结构。在本研究中,焦点小组被用作对患者门诊物理治疗满意度进行多方法研究的一部分;它们为患者评估其护理背后的推理过程提供了额外的宝贵见解。确定患者的需求,特别是这些需求在多大程度上可能是心理社会方面而非身体方面的,可能会为更以患者为中心且富有成效的物理治疗体验指明方向。尽管从这项研究中获得了丰富的深入信息,但由于样本量小以及研究是在国民保健服务体系内进行的,在推广这些发现时应谨慎。因此,需要进一步开展工作,以确定与患者对门诊护理满意度相关的所有问题。