Cantor Chris, Price John
Department of Psychiatry, University of Queensland, PO Box 1216, Noosa Heads, Qld 4567, Australia.
Aust N Z J Psychiatry. 2007 May;41(5):377-84. doi: 10.1080/00048670701261178.
Evolutionary theory and cross-species comparisons are explored to shed new insights into behavioural responses to traumatic entrapment, examining their relationships to the Stockholm syndrome (a specific response to traumatic entrapment) and complex post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). A selective literature review is undertaken examining responses to traumatic entrapment (including hostage, domestic abuse and similar situations) and the Stockholm syndrome, before examining mammalian, reptilian and other defensive responses to relevant threats. Chimpanzees, the closest relatives of humans, are closely examined from this perspective and commonalities in behavioural responses are highlighted. The neurobiological basis of defensive behaviours underlying PTSD is explored with reference to the triune brain model. Victims of protracted traumatic entrapment under certain circumstances may display the Stockholm syndrome, which involves paradoxically positive relationships with their oppressors that may persist beyond release. Similar responses are observed in many mammalian species, especially primates. Ethological concepts including dominance hierarchies, reverted escape, de-escalation and conditional reconciliation appear relevant and are illustrated. These phenomena are commonly encountered in victims of severe abuse and understanding these concepts may assist clinical management. Appeasement is the mammalian defence most relevant to the survival challenge presented by traumatic entrapment and appears to be the foundation of complex PTSD. Evolutionary perspectives have considerable potential to bridge and integrate neurobiology and the social sciences with respect to traumatic stress responses.
本文探讨了进化理论和跨物种比较,以深入了解对创伤性受困的行为反应,研究它们与斯德哥尔摩综合征(对创伤性受困的一种特定反应)和复杂性创伤后应激障碍(PTSD)的关系。在研究哺乳动物、爬行动物及其他对相关威胁的防御反应之前,我们进行了一项选择性文献综述,考察了对创伤性受困(包括人质、家庭虐待及类似情况)的反应以及斯德哥尔摩综合征。从这一角度对人类的近亲黑猩猩进行了深入研究,并突出了行为反应中的共性。参照三位一体大脑模型,探讨了PTSD背后防御行为的神经生物学基础。在某些情况下,长期遭受创伤性受困的受害者可能会表现出斯德哥尔摩综合征,即与压迫者建立起看似矛盾的积极关系,这种关系可能在获释后仍持续存在。在许多哺乳动物物种,尤其是灵长类动物中也观察到了类似反应。文中阐述了包括支配等级制度、反向逃避、缓和及条件性和解在内的行为学概念。这些现象在严重虐待的受害者中很常见,理解这些概念可能有助于临床管理。安抚是与创伤性受困所带来的生存挑战最相关的哺乳动物防御方式,似乎是复杂性PTSD的基础。进化视角在创伤应激反应方面具有相当大的潜力,能够架起神经生物学与社会科学之间的桥梁并实现整合。