Ravery Vincent, Dominique Sébastien, Hupertan Vincent, Ben Rhouma Sami, Toublanc Marianne, Boccon-Gibod Liliane, Boccon-Gibod Laurent
Department of Urology, Bichat Hospital, Paris, France.
Eur Urol. 2008 Mar;53(3):533-8. doi: 10.1016/j.eururo.2007.04.048. Epub 2007 Apr 23.
To investigate the hypothesis that Northern Africans differ from Caucasians with regard to their PCa characteristics, using our 1988-2006 database we retrospectively reviewed the preoperative and pathological features of consecutive patients subjected to radical prostatectomy (RP) for localized prostate cancer (PCa) and stratified according to their ethnic origin.
In 727 consecutive patients (616 Caucasians; 61 Blacks originating from Central Africa and the French West Indies; 50 Northern Africans from Morocco, Algeria, Tunisia), we preoperatively analyzed and compared age, clinical stage of the tumour, prostate-specific antigen (PSA), transrectal ultrasound prostate volume, PSA density (PSAD), biopsy Gleason score, number of positive cores (NPC), and percentage of tissue core invaded by cancer (PTIC); postoperatively, we determined the status of the capsule, seminal vesicles, and margins of the RP specimen, as well as Gleason score and prostate weight. Statistical analyses (chi-square test and ANOVA) were performed to compare the results between the three groups of patients. A multivariate analysis was carried out to test the independence of variables.
Black patients were the youngest at the time of surgery (by 3-4 yr) and had the highest rates of final Gleason score>or=8. The Northern Africans had more favourable features than did Caucasian and Black patients: mean PTIC was 7.1% versus 14.6% and 12.5%, respectively (p=0.005), mean NPC was 26.4% versus 34.7% and 36.4%, respectively (p=0.034), rates of biopsy and final Gleason score>or=8 were significantly lower (p=0.02 and p=0.028, respectively), and there were positive margins in 26% versus 36% and 35.6%, respectively (p>0.05).
This study showed that a French Black population is the most likely of those studied to have unfavourable PCa characteristics at the time of RP. Albeit in a limited series, we show for the first time that Northern Africans have significantly better features in this regard than Caucasians and Blacks. Although Northern Africans did not have a better pathological stage outcome, they did have a more favourable Gleason score.
为了研究“北非人与高加索人在前列腺癌特征方面存在差异”这一假设,我们利用1988 - 2006年的数据库,回顾性分析了因局限性前列腺癌接受根治性前列腺切除术(RP)的连续患者的术前和病理特征,并根据种族来源进行分层。
在727例连续患者中(616例高加索人;61例来自中非和法属西印度群岛的黑人;50例来自摩洛哥、阿尔及利亚、突尼斯的北非人),我们术前分析并比较了年龄、肿瘤临床分期、前列腺特异性抗原(PSA)、经直肠超声测定的前列腺体积、PSA密度(PSAD)、活检Gleason评分、阳性核心数量(NPC)以及癌组织侵袭的组织核心百分比(PTIC);术后,我们确定了RP标本的包膜、精囊和切缘状态,以及Gleason评分和前列腺重量。进行统计学分析(卡方检验和方差分析)以比较三组患者的结果。进行多变量分析以检验变量的独立性。
黑人患者手术时最年轻(年轻3 - 4岁),最终Gleason评分≥8的比例最高。北非人比白人和黑人患者具有更有利的特征:平均PTIC分别为7.1%,而白人和黑人分别为14.6%和12.5%(p = 0.005);平均NPC分别为26.4%,而白人和黑人分别为34.7%和36.4%(p = 0.034);活检和最终Gleason评分≥8的比例显著更低(分别为p = 0.02和p = 0.028),切缘阳性率分别为26%,而白人和黑人分别为36%和35.6%(p>0.05)。
本研究表明,在接受RP时,法国黑人人群是所研究人群中前列腺癌特征最不利的。尽管样本量有限,但我们首次表明,在这方面北非人比白人和黑人具有明显更好的特征。虽然北非人病理分期结果没有更好,但他们的Gleason评分更有利。