Hegaard Hanne K, Kjaergaard Hanne, Møller Lars F, Wachmann Henrik, Ottesen Bent
Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, Hvidovre Hospital, Denmark.
Acta Obstet Gynecol Scand. 2007;86(4):401-6. doi: 10.1080/00016340601147517.
Objective validation of smoking status is necessary. Earlier studies have used saliva cotinine concentrations between 14.2 and 30 ng/ml as cut-off values to distinguish pregnant smokers from non-smokers. However, these cut-offs derive from studies including men and non-pregnant women. This constitutes a problem, as recent studies have reported an accelerated metabolism in pregnant smokers. The aim of this study was to determine the optimum cut-off cotinine level distinguishing pregnant smokers from pregnant non-smokers.
An observational study of 620 pregnant women, 359 self-reported smokers and 261 self-reported non-smokers, with complete data on smoking status and saliva cotinine. The study was conducted at a large university hospital in Copenhagen, Denmark. Saliva was sampled at the first antenatal visit to the midwife and analyzed for cotinine level by gas chromatography. Participants completed a questionnaire immediately after the first visit.
A saliva cotinine cut-off level of 13 ng/ml, corresponding to a sensitivity of 0.99 and specificity 0.98, was found to be the optimum cut-off value separating pregnant smokers from non-smokers. The sum of the sensitivity and specificity was at its maximum, 1.981. A 95% bootstrap confidence interval for the optimum cut-off was (8-14 ng/ml).
From the present data we recommend that in future studies on smoking cessation and pregnancy a cut-off level of 13 ng/ml should be applied to distinguish between pregnant smokers and non-smokers.
吸烟状况的客观验证很有必要。早期研究使用唾液可替宁浓度在14.2至30纳克/毫升之间作为区分怀孕吸烟者和非吸烟者的临界值。然而,这些临界值来自包括男性和非怀孕女性的研究。这就产生了一个问题,因为最近的研究报告称怀孕吸烟者的新陈代谢加快。本研究的目的是确定区分怀孕吸烟者和怀孕非吸烟者的最佳可替宁临界水平。
对620名孕妇进行观察性研究,其中359名自我报告为吸烟者,261名自我报告为非吸烟者,有关于吸烟状况和唾液可替宁的完整数据。该研究在丹麦哥本哈根的一家大型大学医院进行。在首次产前到助产士处就诊时采集唾液,并通过气相色谱法分析可替宁水平。参与者在首次就诊后立即填写问卷。
发现唾液可替宁临界水平为13纳克/毫升,对应灵敏度为0.99,特异性为0.98,是区分怀孕吸烟者和非吸烟者的最佳临界值。灵敏度和特异性之和达到最大值,为1.981。最佳临界值的95%自助置信区间为(8 - 14纳克/毫升)。
根据目前的数据,我们建议在未来关于戒烟与怀孕的研究中,应采用13纳克/毫升的临界水平来区分怀孕吸烟者和非吸烟者。