Sarajlić Nermin, Cihlarz Zdenko
International Commission on Missing Persons, Alipasina 45A, 71000 Sarajevo, Bosnia and Herzegovina.
Bosn J Basic Med Sci. 2007 May;7(2):136-9. doi: 10.17305/bjbms.2007.3068.
Since 1996, the Trotter formulae, developed on American Whites, have been used almost without exception to determine the stature of the population in Bosnia and Herzegovina. In 2002, Ross and Konigsberg presented new formulae for stature estimation for Balkans, using bones from unidentified Bosnian and Croatian males, victims of the recent war. The same year, 2002, in his master thesis, Sarajlić also presented formulae for stature estimation of Bosnian population. The research was undertaken on male cadavers. The cadaver length was measured directly and the length of the long bones was obtained from radiographs. However, none of these formulae were tested on the bones from exhumed persons. This study compares all three methods on a large independent sample in order to determine which formulae provide the most accurate stature estimation for the male population in Bosnia and Herzegovina. The sample for this research consists of long bones (humerus, femur, tibia and fibula) and was obtained from 369 exhumed and identified Bosnian males. Bones from the left side of the body were tested. Not all of them were present in each case: 211 left humeri, 270 left femura, 273 left tibiae and 175 left fibulae. Data about height was recollected by family members. Apart of whole sample, all three methods were applied separately on individuals taller then 180 cm. Of all three tested methods formulae proposed by Sarajlić et al. folowed by Ross and Konigsberg formulae, produced significantly better results in stature estimation of tall persons.
自1996年以来,基于美国白人得出的特罗特公式几乎毫无例外地被用于确定波斯尼亚和黑塞哥维那人口的身高。2002年,罗斯和柯尼斯伯格利用最近战争中身份不明的波斯尼亚和克罗地亚男性受害者的骨骼,提出了用于巴尔干地区身高估计的新公式。同年,2002年,萨拉伊奇在其硕士论文中也提出了波斯尼亚人口身高估计的公式。该研究是在男性尸体上进行的。直接测量尸体长度,并从X光片中获取长骨的长度。然而,这些公式都没有在挖掘出的人员的骨骼上进行测试。本研究在一个大型独立样本上比较了所有三种方法,以确定哪些公式能为波斯尼亚和黑塞哥维那的男性人口提供最准确的身高估计。本研究的样本包括长骨(肱骨、股骨、胫骨和腓骨),取自369名已挖掘出并已确认身份的波斯尼亚男性。对身体左侧的骨骼进行了测试。并非每种情况都有所有的骨骼:211根左肱骨、270根左股骨、273根左胫骨和175根左腓骨。身高数据由家庭成员提供。除了整个样本外,所有三种方法都分别应用于身高超过180厘米的个体。在所有三种测试方法中,萨拉伊奇等人提出的公式,其次是罗斯和柯尼斯伯格的公式,在高个子的身高估计中产生了明显更好的结果。