Eytan Ariel, Jene-Petschen Nuria, Gex-Fabry Marianne
Department of Psychiatry, Adult Psychiatric Service, Geneva University Hospitals, Switzerland.
BMC Psychiatry. 2007 May 9;7:17. doi: 10.1186/1471-244X-7-17.
Acculturation is one of the determinants of mental health among immigrants. Evaluating adaptation to the host culture is insufficient, since immigrants will develop various degrees of bi- or multicultural identity. However, mental health professionals lack simple and easy to use instruments to guide them with bicultural identity evaluation in their practice. Our aim was to develop such an instrument to be used for clinical purposes among economical migrants from three South European countries living in Geneva, Switzerland.
We adapted from existing instruments a 24 item bi-dimensional scale to assess involvement in both culture of origin and host culture. The study included 93 immigrant adults from three south European countries (Italy, Portugal and Spain). Thirty-eight patients were recruited in an outpatient treatment program for alcohol-related problems and 55 participants were hospital employees.
The questionnaire was rated as easy or rather easy by 97.8% of participants. Median time to complete it was 5 minutes. The instrument allowed discriminating between patients and healthy subjects, with scores for Swiss culture significantly higher among hospital workers. The subscales related to culture of origin and host culture displayed adequate internal consistency (Cronbach's alpha 0.77 and 0.73 respectively).
It is possible to assist clinicians' assessment of cultural identity of Italian, Portuguese and Spanish economical immigrants in Switzerland with a single and easy to use instrument.
文化适应是移民心理健康的决定因素之一。仅评估对东道国文化的适应是不够的,因为移民会形成不同程度的双重或多元文化身份认同。然而,心理健康专业人员缺乏简单易用的工具来指导他们在实践中进行双文化身份评估。我们的目标是开发这样一种工具,用于对居住在瑞士日内瓦的来自三个南欧国家的经济移民进行临床评估。
我们从现有工具改编了一个包含24个条目的二维量表,以评估对原籍文化和东道国文化的参与程度。该研究纳入了93名来自三个南欧国家(意大利、葡萄牙和西班牙)的成年移民。38名患者是从一个针对酒精相关问题的门诊治疗项目中招募的,55名参与者是医院员工。
97.8%的参与者认为问卷容易或比较容易填写。完成问卷的中位时间为5分钟。该工具能够区分患者和健康受试者,医院工作人员在瑞士文化方面的得分显著更高。与原籍文化和东道国文化相关的子量表显示出足够的内部一致性(Cronbach's alpha分别为0.77和0.73)。
使用单一且易于使用的工具来协助临床医生评估瑞士的意大利、葡萄牙和西班牙经济移民的文化身份是可行的。