Al-Samarrai Nahla R, Uman Gwen C, Al-Samarrai Teeb, Alessi Cathy A
Statistics Plus, Inc, Torrance, CA 90505, USA.
J Am Med Dir Assoc. 2007 May;8(4):253-61. doi: 10.1016/j.jamda.2006.10.001. Epub 2007 Jan 9.
To describe current practices of incontinence care in nursing homes (NHs) provided by certified nurse assistants (CNAs), and to evaluate the feasibility and acceptability of an integrated incontinence care product, the One Step Incontinence System (OSIS) in the NH setting. While the ultimate purpose of OSIS is to encourage more consistent skin cleansing and thus reduce perineal dermatitis and risk of pressure ulcers, this study reports an initial feasibility test of OSIS.
Controlled trial at two NH sites, with one ward at each site assigned to intervention with OSIS and one ward at each site assigned to a control condition with a box of wipes placed at the bedside (BW).
Two NHs (one community and one Veterans Administration) in the Los Angeles area.
24 incontinent NH residents and 61 CNAs.
OSIS integrates an adult brief and two cleansing/protective wipes into a single item by way of a waterproof pouch that is removed at the time of incontinence care. The OSIS briefs were placed on the intervention wards in the same location(s) and adjacent to regular adult briefs.
Structured observations of incontinence care episodes were performed by trained research staff at baseline on all wards, and at follow-up with either the intervention (OSIS) or control condition (BW) in place. Observations included resident location, thoroughness and duration of incontinence care, and materials used. In addition, CNAs' opinions of their preferred incontinence care materials and their experience using OSIS were obtained by self-administered survey.
Use of OSIS resulted in significantly greater frequency of use of cleansing wipes (97% of episodes) compared to the baseline (77% of episodes) and BW conditions (41% of episodes). In 59% of the observed episodes in the BW condition, the box of wipes was actually missing from the bedside, or completely absent from the patient's room and had to be replaced. The two wipes that were incorporated with OSIS were used for perineal skin cleansing immediately when providing incontinence care. There was a significant reduction in the percentage use of and number of cloth towels used during incontinence care with OSIS (53% of episodes, 0.8 towels) compared to baseline (67%, 1.1 towels) and BW conditions (82%, 1.2 towels; p=.002 and p=.012, respectively). CNAs were significantly less often interrupted by the need to find supplies during OSIS condition (13%) compared to baseline (23%) and BW (36%; p= .005). There were no significant differences between conditions in the thoroughness of observed cleansing. The average observed time for incontinence care from putting on gloves to fastening the clean adult brief (T1) and between uncovering the resident to fastening a clean adult brief (T2) decreased significantly within both groups (OSIS and BW) at follow-up (all p-values <.05), but there were no significant differences in T1 and T2 between groups at follow-up. CNAs were more likely to report that they felt that OSIS facilitated skin cleansing compared to the BW.
We successfully implemented a trial of an innovative adult brief that encouraged skin cleansing during incontinence care. The system was easily and effectively incorporated into the nursing home, was used by CNAs whenever available (97% of the time), and was favored by CNAs. Patterns of incontinence care differed at follow-up with OSIS compared to BW, with fewer linens used, fewer wipes used, and less CNA interruption during care, which may result in greater privacy and comfort for residents.
描述注册护士助理(CNA)在养老院提供失禁护理的当前做法,并评估一种综合失禁护理产品——一步式失禁护理系统(OSIS)在养老院环境中的可行性和可接受性。虽然OSIS的最终目的是鼓励更持续地进行皮肤清洁,从而减少会阴皮炎和压疮风险,但本研究报告了OSIS的初步可行性测试。
在两个养老院进行对照试验,每个养老院的一个病房分配使用OSIS进行干预,每个养老院的另一个病房分配为对照条件,在床边放置一盒擦拭巾(BW)。
洛杉矶地区的两家养老院(一家社区养老院和一家退伍军人管理局养老院)。
24名失禁的养老院居民和61名CNA。
OSIS通过一个防水袋将成人纸尿裤和两片清洁/防护擦拭巾整合为一个物品,在进行失禁护理时将防水袋取下。OSIS纸尿裤放置在干预病房的相同位置,并与常规成人纸尿裤相邻。
由经过培训的研究人员在基线时对所有病房进行失禁护理事件的结构化观察,并在干预(OSIS)或对照条件(BW)实施后的随访中进行观察。观察内容包括居民位置、失禁护理的彻底程度和持续时间以及使用的材料。此外,通过自行填写的调查问卷获取CNA对其首选失禁护理材料的意见以及他们使用OSIS的经验。
与基线(77%的护理事件)和BW条件(41%的护理事件)相比,使用OSIS导致清洁擦拭巾的使用频率显著更高(97%的护理事件)。在BW条件下观察到的59%的护理事件中,床边的擦拭巾盒实际上不见了,或者完全不在患者房间,必须更换。与OSIS整合在一起的两片擦拭巾在提供失禁护理时立即用于会阴皮肤清洁。与基线(67%,1.条毛巾)和BW条件(82%,1.2条毛巾;p分别为0.002和0.012)相比,使用OSIS进行失禁护理时,毛巾的使用百分比和使用数量显著减少(53%的护理事件,0.8条毛巾)。与基线(23%)和BW(36%;p = 0.005)相比,在OSIS条件下,CNA因寻找用品而被打断的情况显著减少(13%)。观察到的清洁彻底程度在不同条件之间没有显著差异。在随访时两组(OSIS组和BW组)中,从戴上手套到系好干净成人纸尿裤的失禁护理平均观察时间(T1)以及从揭开居民到系好干净成人纸尿裤的平均观察时间(T2)均显著缩短(所有p值 < 0.05),但随访时两组之间的T1和T2没有显著差异。与BW相比,CNA更有可能报告他们认为OSIS便于进行皮肤清洁。
我们成功实施了一项关于创新型成人纸尿裤的试验,该纸尿裤鼓励在失禁护理期间进行皮肤清洁。该系统易于且有效地融入了养老院,CNA只要有机会就会使用(97%的时间),并且受到CNA的青睐。与BW相比,随访时使用OSIS的失禁护理模式有所不同,使用的床单更少、擦拭巾更少,护理期间CNA被打断的情况也更少,这可能会为居民带来更大的隐私和舒适度。