Fernández-de-Las-Peñas César, Cuadrado Maria L, Pareja Juan A
Department of Physical Therapy, Occupational Therapy, Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation of Universidad Rey Juan Carlos, Alcorcón, Madrid, Spain.
Headache. 2007 May;47(5):662-72. doi: 10.1111/j.1526-4610.2006.00632.x.
To assess the differences in the presence of trigger points (TrPs) in head and neck muscles, forward head posture (FHP) and neck mobility between episodic tension-type headache (ETTH) subjects and healthy controls. In addition, we assess the relationship between these muscle TrPs, FHP, neck mobility, and several clinical variables concerning the intensity and the temporal profile of headache.
TTH is a headache in which musculoskeletal disorders of the craniocervical region might play an important role in its pathogenesis. Design.-A blinded, controlled pilot study.
Fifteen ETTH subjects and 15 matched controls without headache were studied. TrPs in both upper trapezius, both sternocleidomastoids, and both temporalis muscles were identified according to Simons and Gerwin diagnostic criteria (tenderness in a hypersensible spot within a palpable taut band, local twitch response elicited by snapping palpation, and elicited referred pain with palpation). Side-view pictures of each subject were taken in both sitting and standing positions, in order to assess FHP by measuring the craniovertebral angle. A cervical goniometer was employed to measure neck mobility. All measures were taken by a blinded assessor. A headache diary was kept for 4 weeks in order to assess headache intensity, frequency, and duration.
The mean number of TrPs for each ETTH subject was 3.7 (SD: 1.3), of which 1.9 (SD: 0.9) were active, and 1.8 (SD: 0.9) were latent. Control subjects only had latent TrPs (mean: 1.5; SD: 1). TrP occurrence between the 2 groups was significantly different for active TrPs (P < .001), but not for latent TrPs (P > .05). Differences in the distribution of TrPs were significant for the right upper trapezius muscles (P= .04), the left sternocleidomastoid (P= .03), and both temporalis muscles (P < .001). Within the ETTH group, headache intensity, frequency, and duration outcomes did not differ depending on TrP activity, whether the TrP was active or latent. The craniovertebral angle was smaller, ie, there was a greater FHP, in ETTH patients than in healthy controls for both sitting and standing positions (P < .05). ETTH subjects with active TrPs in the analyzed muscles had a greater FHP than those with latent TrPs in both sitting and standing positions, though differences were only significant for certain muscles. Finally, ETTH patients also showed lesser neck mobility than healthy controls in the total range of motion as well as in half-cycles (except for cervical extension), although neck mobility did not seem to influence headache parameters.
Active TrPs in the upper trapezius, sternocleidomastoid, and temporalis muscles were more common in ETTH subjects than in healthy controls, although TrP activity was not related to any clinical variable concerning the intensity and the temporal profile of headache. ETTH patients showed greater FHP and lesser neck mobility than healthy controls, although both disorders were not correlated with headache parameters.
评估发作性紧张型头痛(ETTH)患者与健康对照者在头颈部肌肉触发点(TrP)的存在情况、头前伸姿势(FHP)和颈部活动度方面的差异。此外,我们评估这些肌肉TrP、FHP、颈部活动度与若干有关头痛强度和时间特征的临床变量之间的关系。
紧张型头痛是一种颅颈区域肌肉骨骼疾病可能在其发病机制中起重要作用的头痛。设计:一项双盲、对照的前瞻性研究。
对15例ETTH患者和15例无头痛的匹配对照者进行研究。根据西蒙斯和格温诊断标准(在可触及的紧张带内的高敏点压痛、弹拨触诊引发局部抽搐反应以及触诊引发牵涉痛)确定双侧斜方肌上部、双侧胸锁乳突肌和双侧颞肌中的TrP。为评估FHP,通过测量颅椎角,在坐位和站位分别拍摄每个受试者的侧视图照片。使用颈椎角度计测量颈部活动度。所有测量均由一名盲法评估者进行。记录头痛日记4周,以评估头痛强度、频率和持续时间。
每名ETTH患者的TrP平均数量为3.7个(标准差:1.3),其中1.9个(标准差:0.9)为活动性TrP,1.8个(标准差:0.9)为潜伏性TrP。对照者仅存在潜伏性TrP(平均:1.5;标准差:1)。两组之间活动性TrP的TrP发生率差异有统计学意义(P <.001),但潜伏性TrP无差异(P >.05)。右侧斜方肌上部(P =.04)、左侧胸锁乳突肌(P =.03)和双侧颞肌(P <.001)的TrP分布差异有统计学意义。在ETTH组内,无论TrP是活动性还是潜伏性,头痛强度、频率和持续时间结果均不因TrP活动情况而异。对于坐位和站位,ETTH患者的颅椎角均小于健康对照者,即存在更大的FHP(P <.05)。在分析的肌肉中存在活动性TrP的ETTH患者在坐位和站位时的FHP均大于存在潜伏性TrP的患者,尽管差异仅在某些肌肉中具有统计学意义。最后,ETTH患者在总活动范围以及半周期(颈椎伸展除外)的颈部活动度也低于健康对照者,尽管颈部活动度似乎不影响头痛参数。
ETTH患者斜方肌上部、胸锁乳突肌和颞肌中的活动性TrP比健康对照者更常见,尽管TrP活动与任何有关头痛强度和时间特征的临床变量均无关。ETTH患者比健康对照者表现出更大的FHP和更小的颈部活动度,尽管这两种异常均与头痛参数无关。