Höytö A, Juutilainen J, Naarala J
Department of Environmental Science, University of Kuopio, Kuopio, Finland.
Bioelectromagnetics. 2007 Oct;28(7):501-8. doi: 10.1002/bem.20337.
A replication study with some extensions was made to confirm enhancement of ornithine decarboxylase (ODC) activity in murine L929 fibroblasts after radiofrequency (RF) field exposure reported in earlier studies. L929 cells purchased from two cell banks were exposed for 2, 8, or 24 h to continuous wave or DAMPS (burst modulated at 50 Hz, with 33% duty cycle) signals at specific absorption rate (SAR) levels of 2.5 or 6.0 W/kg. Exposures were carried out in Crawford and waveguide chambers, at frequencies 835 and 872 MHz, respectively. The results did not confirm findings of previous studies reporting increased ODC activity in RF-exposed cells. When Crawford cell exposure system was used, ODC activity was either not affected (in the case of 8 or 24 h exposures) or decreased after 2 h exposure at the highest SAR level (6 W/kg). The decrease was most pronounced when cooling with air flow was not used, and is most likely related to increased temperature. The minor methodological differences (use of antibiotics, increased sensitivity of ODC assay) are not likely to explain the inconsistency of the findings of the present and previous studies. Different results were obtained in experiments with the waveguide system that involves more efficient temperature control. In this exposure system, ODC activity was increased after 8 h exposure at 6 W/kg. Further studies are warranted to explore whether this finding reflects a true non-thermal effect. The present study did not provide evidence for modulation-specific effects reported in earlier studies.
开展了一项进行了一些扩展的重复研究,以证实早期研究报道的射频(RF)场暴露后小鼠L929成纤维细胞中鸟氨酸脱羧酶(ODC)活性增强的现象。从两个细胞库购买的L929细胞分别在2.5或6.0 W/kg的比吸收率(SAR)水平下,暴露于连续波或DAMPS(50 Hz猝发调制,占空比33%)信号2、8或24小时。暴露分别在克劳福德室和波导室中进行,频率分别为835和872 MHz。结果未证实先前研究中关于射频暴露细胞中ODC活性增加的发现。当使用克劳福德细胞暴露系统时,ODC活性要么不受影响(8或24小时暴露的情况),要么在最高SAR水平(6 W/kg)下暴露2小时后降低。在不使用气流冷却时,这种降低最为明显,很可能与温度升高有关。微小的方法学差异(使用抗生素、ODC测定灵敏度提高)不太可能解释本研究和先前研究结果的不一致。在涉及更有效温度控制的波导系统实验中获得了不同的结果。在这个暴露系统中,在6 W/kg下暴露8小时后ODC活性增加。有必要进一步研究这一发现是否反映了真正的非热效应。本研究没有为早期研究报道的调制特异性效应提供证据。