Min Lillian C, Wenger Neil S, Fung Constance, Chang John T, Ganz David A, Higashi Takahiro, Kamberg Caren J, MacLean Catherine H, Roth Carol P, Solomon David H, Young Roy T, Reuben David B
David Geffen School of Medicine at UCLA, Los Angeles, California 90095-1687, USA.
Med Care. 2007 Jun;45(6):480-8. doi: 10.1097/MLR.0b013e318030fff9.
Older patients with multiple chronic conditions may be at higher risk of receiving poorer overall quality of care compared with those with single or no chronic conditions. Possible reasons include competing guidelines for individual conditions, burden of numerous recommendations, and difficulty implementing treatments for multiple conditions.
We sought to determine whether coexisting combinations of 8 common chronic conditions (hypertension, coronary artery disease, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, osteoarthritis, diabetes mellitus, depression, osteoporosis, and having atrial fibrillation or congestive heart failure) are associated with overall quality of care among vulnerable older patients.
Using an observational cohort study, we enrolled 372 community-dwelling persons 65 years of age or older who were at increased risk for death or functional decline within 2 years. We included (1) a comprehensive measure (% of quality indicators satisfied) of quality of medical and geriatric care that accounted for patient preference and appropriateness in light of limited life expectancy and advanced dementia, and (2) a measure of multimorbidity, either as a simple count of conditions or as a combination of specific conditions.
: Multimorbidity was associated with greater overall quality scores: mean proportion of quality indicators satisfied increased from 47% for elders with none of the prespecified conditions to 59% for those with 5 or 6 conditions (P < 0.0001), after controlling for number of office visits. Patients with greater multimorbidity also received care that was better than would be expected based on the specific set of quality indicators they triggered.
Among older persons at increased risk of death or functional decline, multimorbidity results in better, rather than worse, quality of care.
与患有单一慢性病或无慢性病的患者相比,患有多种慢性病的老年患者获得的整体护理质量可能更低。可能的原因包括针对个体疾病的相互冲突的指南、众多建议带来的负担以及实施多种疾病治疗的困难。
我们试图确定8种常见慢性病(高血压、冠状动脉疾病、慢性阻塞性肺疾病、骨关节炎、糖尿病、抑郁症、骨质疏松症以及患有心房颤动或充血性心力衰竭)的共存组合是否与脆弱老年患者的整体护理质量相关。
采用观察性队列研究,我们纳入了372名65岁及以上的社区居住者,他们在2年内死亡或功能衰退的风险增加。我们纳入了(1)一项综合指标(质量指标的满足率),该指标考虑了患者的偏好以及鉴于预期寿命有限和晚期痴呆的适当性,用于衡量医疗和老年护理质量;(2)一项共病指标,既可以是疾病的简单计数,也可以是特定疾病的组合。
共病与更高的整体质量得分相关:在控制就诊次数后,质量指标的平均满足率从没有预先指定疾病的老年人的47%增加到患有5种或6种疾病的老年人的59%(P < 0.0001)。共病程度更高的患者接受的护理也比根据他们触发的特定质量指标集预期的要好。
在死亡或功能衰退风险增加的老年人中,共病导致的护理质量更好,而非更差。