Campbell Michelle L C, Morrison Anthony P
Department of Psychology, University of Manchester, UK.
Br J Clin Psychol. 2007 Jun;46(Pt 2):187-201. doi: 10.1348/014466506X128287.
The aim of the current study is to explore the association between combat experience and the occurrence of delusional-like beliefs. It is hypothesized that negative post-trauma appraisals and positive beliefs about paranoia will be associated with vulnerability to delusional ideas and that veterans who meet criteria for post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) will be more likely to hold delusional-like ideas.
A small-scale survey design was employed in order to ensure that detailed information was gathered concerning battle exposure.
Forty-one British war veterans completed questionnaires relating to combat experience, delusional ideation, beliefs about paranoia, appraisals of combat trauma and PTSD symptomatology.
Negative post-trauma cognitions and positive and negative beliefs about paranoia were associated with increased predisposition to delusional beliefs; however, the severity of combat experience was not. It was also found that veterans who met criteria for PTSD were more likely to hold delusional-like ideas compared with those who did not. Furthermore, the PTSD group held more negative post-trauma cognitions and more positive beliefs about paranoia.
These findings suggest that PTSD symptoms may confer vulnerability to delusional beliefs and that this may be mediated by negative appraisals about the self, the world and dysfunctional beliefs about paranoia. However, it is possible that psychotic-like phenomena confer vulnerability to PTSD. The implications of these findings are discussed.
本研究旨在探讨战斗经历与类妄想信念的发生之间的关联。研究假设创伤后消极评估以及对偏执的积极信念将与类妄想观念的易感性相关,并且符合创伤后应激障碍(PTSD)标准的退伍军人更有可能持有类妄想观念。
采用小规模调查设计,以确保收集到有关战斗暴露的详细信息。
41名英国退伍军人完成了与战斗经历、妄想观念、对偏执的信念、战斗创伤评估以及PTSD症状学相关的问卷。
创伤后消极认知以及对偏执的积极和消极信念与类妄想信念的易感性增加相关;然而,战斗经历的严重程度并非如此。研究还发现,符合PTSD标准的退伍军人比不符合标准的退伍军人更有可能持有类妄想观念。此外,PTSD组持有更多的创伤后消极认知以及对偏执的更积极信念。
这些发现表明,PTSD症状可能使人易患类妄想信念,并且这可能由对自我、世界的消极评估以及对偏执的功能失调信念所介导。然而,类精神病现象也有可能使人易患PTSD。讨论了这些发现的意义。