Bhavsar Satyendra P, Fletcher Rachael, Hayton Alan, Reiner Eric J, Jackson Donald A
Department of Ecology and Evolutionary Biology, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario M5S 3G5, Canada.
Environ Sci Technol. 2007 May 1;41(9):3096-102. doi: 10.1021/es062402y.
It is widely accepted that a congener-specific analysis of polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs), rather than traditional Aroclor equivalent total PCB analysis, is required for risk assessment. This is based on the fact that environmental processes alter the original distribution of PCB congeners in Aroclors and that toxicity varies considerably among the congeners with dioxin-like PCBs (dl-PCBs) generally being among the most toxic. Using the largest known dl-PCB fish dataset, here we present a likely composition of dl-PCBs in fish. In contrast to common perception, we found that the dl-PCB composition is relatively constant (within approximately a factor of 2) regardless of fish species and total PCB level. The abundance of dl-PCBs expressed as a percentage of total PCB (25-75 quartile range) in fish is generally in the order of PCB-118 (3.0-6.2%) > PCB-105 (1.1-2.4%) > PCB-156 (0.39-0.75%) > PCB-167 (0.20-0.43%) > PCB-123 (0.11-0.26%) > PCB-157 (0.09-0.19%) = PCB-114 (0.08-0.18%) > PCB-189 (0.045-0.094%) > PCB-77 (0.018-0.093%) > PCB-126 (0.015-0.036%) > PCB-81 (0.002-0.007%) = PCB-169 (0.001-0.006%). The most toxic dl-PCB congeners PCB-126 and -169 contribute on average only 0.027 and 0.004% of total PCB, respectively. The statistically significant relationships presented between individual di-PCB and total-PCB concentrations can be used as a practical tool to estimate dl-PCBs for risk assessment purposes. A comparison of the dl-PCB pattern presented here with other studies suggests that this dl-PCB composition is applicable to fish from North America and perhaps from other geographical regions throughout the world.
人们普遍认为,多氯联苯(PCBs)的同类物特异性分析而非传统的艾氏剂当量总多氯联苯分析,对于风险评估而言是必要的。这是基于以下事实:环境过程会改变多氯联苯同类物在艾氏剂中的原始分布,并且不同同类物的毒性差异很大,其中类二噁英多氯联苯(dl - PCBs)通常是毒性最强的。利用已知最大的类二噁英多氯联苯鱼类数据集,我们在此展示了鱼类中类二噁英多氯联苯可能的组成。与普遍认知相反,我们发现无论鱼类种类和总多氯联苯水平如何,类二噁英多氯联苯的组成相对恒定(在约2倍的范围内)。以鱼类中总多氯联苯的百分比表示的类二噁英多氯联苯丰度(第25 - 75四分位数范围)通常顺序为:多氯联苯 - 118(3.0 - 6.2%)> 多氯联苯 - 105(1.1 - 2.4%)> 多氯联苯 - 156(0.39 - 0.75%)> 多氯联苯 - 167(0.20 - 0.43%)> 多氯联苯 - 123(0.11 - 0.26%)> 多氯联苯 - 157(0.09 - 0.19%) = 多氯联苯 - 114(0.08 - 0.18%)> 多氯联苯 - 189(0.045 - 0.094%)> 多氯联苯 - 77(0.018 - 0.093%)> 多氯联苯 - 126(0.015 - 0.036%)> 多氯联苯 - 81(0.002 - 0.007%) = 多氯联苯 - 169(0.001 - 0.006%)。毒性最强的类二噁英多氯联苯同类物多氯联苯 - 1 和 - 169分别仅占总多氯联苯的0.027%和0.004%。所呈现的单个二噁英多氯联苯与总多氯联苯浓度之间具有统计学意义的关系,可作为一种实用工具,用于风险评估目的来估计类二噁英多氯联苯。将此处呈现的类二噁英多氯联苯模式与其他研究进行比较表明,这种类二噁英多氯联苯组成适用于来自北美的鱼类,也许还适用于世界其他地理区域的鱼类。