Aktan Sebnem, Akarsu Sevgi, Ilknur Turna, Demirtaşoğlu Melda, Ozkan Sebnem
Department of Dermatology, Dokuz Eylul University School of Medicine, 35340 Inciralti, Izmir, Turkey.
Eur J Dermatol. 2007 Jul-Aug;17(4):321-4. doi: 10.1684/ejd.2007.0208. Epub 2007 Jun 1.
Studies dealing with the relationship between the clinical staging of female pattern hair loss (FPHL) and quantitative measurements of hair parameters are limited. This study was performed to quantify Turkish women's hair characteristics in FPHL, to assess the relationship between clinical presentations of FPHL with hair density and anagen hair ratio and to compare the differences in hair parameters between FPHL and normal women, using epiluminescence microscopy combined with digital image analysis (Trichoscan). Hair density and anagen hair ratio measurements of 39 patients with FPHL were evaluated according to clinical stages and compared with those of 31 healthy volunteers. The results of digital image analysis were compared with the results of visual counting using the photomacrographs of the same images. Mid-scalp hair density and anagen ratio of the patients were detected to be significantly lower than those of the controls. The visual counting detected significant differences among the hair densities of all groups including controls, Ludwig I, and Ludwig II/III groups, while digital image analysis revealed a significant difference only between controls and Ludwig II/III groups. Thus digital image analysis was found to underestimate hair density, and the amount of underestimation demonstrated a positive correlation with hair density. In conclusion, diminished hair density seems to be the main sign in the clinical diagnosis of hair loss, although digital image analysis was found to be less competent than visual counting in detecting hair density. Thus, the increase in hair density in the assessment of various treatment modality effects may be underestimated by digital image analysis.
关于女性型脱发(FPHL)临床分期与毛发参数定量测量之间关系的研究有限。本研究旨在通过落射荧光显微镜结合数字图像分析(Trichoscan)对土耳其女性FPHL的毛发特征进行量化,评估FPHL临床表现与毛发密度及生长期毛发比例之间的关系,并比较FPHL女性与正常女性之间毛发参数的差异。根据临床分期对39例FPHL患者的毛发密度和生长期毛发比例测量结果进行评估,并与31名健康志愿者的结果进行比较。将数字图像分析结果与使用相同图像的放大照片进行视觉计数的结果进行比较。检测发现患者头皮中部的毛发密度和生长期比例显著低于对照组。视觉计数发现包括对照组、路德维希I级和路德维希II/III级组在内的所有组的毛发密度之间存在显著差异,而数字图像分析仅显示对照组与路德维希II/III级组之间存在显著差异。因此,发现数字图像分析会低估毛发密度,且低估程度与毛发密度呈正相关。总之,毛发密度降低似乎是脱发临床诊断的主要体征,尽管发现数字图像分析在检测毛发密度方面不如视觉计数。因此,在评估各种治疗方式效果时,数字图像分析可能会低估毛发密度的增加。