Farr Sherry L, Jamieson Denise J, Rivera Hirmice Vásquez, Ahmed Yusuf, Heilig Charles M
Division of Reproductive Health, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, Georgia 30341, USA.
Obstet Gynecol. 2007 Jun;109(6):1351-7. doi: 10.1097/01.AOG.0000263460.39686.da.
The rate of primary cesarean delivery in Puerto Rico in 2002 was 52% higher than in 1996 and 85% higher than among Puerto Rican women delivering on the U.S. mainland. Reasons for these differences were explored using birth certificate data.
Distributions of mothers' age, education, parity, level of prenatal care, pregnancy weight gain, medical risk factors, labor induction, labor or delivery complications, and infant birth weight among births in Puerto Rico in 2002 (n=40,489) were compared with births in Puerto Rico in 1996 (n=51,357) and births to Puerto Rican women delivering on the mainland in 2002 (n=47,800). Multivariable log-linear regression models were used to estimate relative risks for primary cesarean delivery by year, place of delivery, and selected risk factors.
Risk for cesarean delivery was higher in Puerto Rico in 2002 than in both 1996 (relative risk 2.1, 95% confidence interval 2.0, 2.3) and on the mainland in 2002 (relative risk 2.4, 95% confidence interval 2.2, 2.6). This translates into one additional cesarean delivery in Puerto Rico in 2002 for every 4.2 live births, controlled for examined risk factors. Higher rates of cesarean delivery in Puerto Rico in 2002 could not be explained by examined risk factors.
Until further research reveals ways to safely reduce the rate of cesarean delivery in Puerto Rico, physicians, public health practitioners, and other stakeholders may want to focus their efforts on reducing rates among low-risk women and those with no labor complications.
II.
2002年波多黎各的首次剖宫产率比1996年高52%,比在美国本土分娩的波多黎各妇女高85%。利用出生证明数据探究了这些差异的原因。
将2002年波多黎各出生的婴儿(n = 40489)的母亲年龄、教育程度、产次、产前护理水平、孕期体重增加、医学风险因素、引产、分娩或接生并发症以及婴儿出生体重的分布情况,与1996年波多黎各出生的婴儿(n = 51357)以及2002年在美国本土分娩的波多黎各妇女所生婴儿(n = 47800)的情况进行比较。采用多变量对数线性回归模型来估计按年份、分娩地点和选定风险因素划分的首次剖宫产的相对风险。
2002年波多黎各的剖宫产风险高于1996年(相对风险2.1,95%置信区间2.0,2.3)和2002年的美国本土(相对风险2.4,95%置信区间2.2,2.6)。这意味着在2002年的波多黎各,每4.2例活产中就有1例额外的剖宫产,已对所检查的风险因素进行了控制。2002年波多黎各较高的剖宫产率无法用所检查的风险因素来解释。
在进一步研究揭示出安全降低波多黎各剖宫产率的方法之前,医生、公共卫生从业者和其他利益相关者可能需要将工作重点放在降低低风险妇女和无分娩并发症妇女的剖宫产率上。
II级