Galbe Mats, Sassner Per, Wingren Anders, Zacchi Guido
Department of Chemical Engineering, Lund University, P.O. Box 124, 221 00, Lund, Sweden.
Adv Biochem Eng Biotechnol. 2007;108:303-27. doi: 10.1007/10_2007_063.
This work presents a review of studies on the process economics of ethanol production from lignocellulosic materials published since 1996. Our objective was to identify the most costly process steps and the impact of various parameters on the final production cost, e.g. plant capacity, raw material cost, and overall product yield, as well as process configuration. The variation in estimated ethanol production cost is considerable, ranging from about 0.13 to 0.81 US$ per liter ethanol. This can be explained to a large extent by actual process differences and variations in the assumptions underlying the techno-economic evaluations. The most important parameters for the economic outcome are the feedstock cost, which varied between 30 and 90 US$ per metric ton in the papers studied, and the plant capacity, which influences the capital cost. To reduce the ethanol production cost it is necessary to reach high ethanol yields, as well as a high ethanol concentration during fermentation, to be able to decrease the energy required for distillation and other downstream process steps. Improved pretreatment methods, enhanced enzymatic hydrolysis with cheaper and more effective enzymes, as well as improved fermentation systems present major research challenges if we are to make lignocellulose-based ethanol production competitive with sugar- and starch-based ethanol. Process integration, either internally or externally with other types of plants, e.g. heat and power plants, also offers a way of reducing the final ethanol production cost.
本文对1996年以来发表的关于木质纤维素材料生产乙醇的工艺经济学研究进行了综述。我们的目标是确定成本最高的工艺步骤,以及各种参数对最终生产成本的影响,例如工厂产能、原材料成本、总产品产率以及工艺配置。估计的乙醇生产成本变化很大,每升乙醇从约0.13美元到0.81美元不等。这在很大程度上可以通过实际工艺差异以及技术经济评估所依据假设的变化来解释。对经济结果最重要的参数是原料成本(在所研究的论文中,原料成本在每吨30美元至90美元之间变化)和工厂产能(工厂产能会影响资本成本)。为了降低乙醇生产成本,有必要在发酵过程中实现高乙醇产率以及高乙醇浓度,以便能够减少蒸馏和其他下游工艺步骤所需的能量。如果要使基于木质纤维素的乙醇生产与基于糖和淀粉的乙醇生产具有竞争力,改进预处理方法、使用更便宜且更有效的酶增强酶水解以及改进发酵系统都面临着重大的研究挑战。工艺整合,无论是在内部还是与其他类型的工厂(例如热电厂)进行外部整合,也提供了一种降低最终乙醇生产成本的方法。