Stuber Kent, Kristmanson Kevyn
Private Practice, 19-8 Weston Drive SW, Calgary, Alberta, Canada.
J Can Chiropr Assoc. 2006 Jun;50(2):118-33.
A narrative literature review of RCTs only, was conducted to ascertain which conservative treatments provide the best results for plantar fasciitis patients. Stretching, prefabricated and custom-made orthotics and night splints have all been scrutinized in numerous studies with mixed results. Chiropractic manipulative therapy has been examined in one study, with favorable results. Therapeutic ultrasound and low intensity laser therapy have been examined in one study apiece with unsatisfactory results. Based on the trials reviewed a trial of therapy beginning with low-cost, patient-centered treatments is recommended, particularly stretching, over-the-counter orthotics, and patient education. Several (but not all) of the reviewed articles indicated that custom-made orthoses are more beneficial for plantar fasciitis than over-the-counter orthotics. In the event these treatments do not provide satisfactory results, use of night splints should be considered. Based on this review, there is no support for the use of magnetic insoles for plantar fasciitis. Most of the studies were found to have at least one methodological flaw, including inadequate sample sizes, high drop-out rates, comparing multiple interventions to multiple interventions (thus making it difficult to determine the effect of each individual intervention) and lack of long-term follow-up. Outcome measure use between studies was inconsistent.
仅对随机对照试验进行了叙述性文献综述,以确定哪些保守治疗方法能为足底筋膜炎患者带来最佳疗效。拉伸、预制和定制矫形器以及夜间夹板在众多研究中均受到了审视,但结果不一。整脊手法治疗在一项研究中得到了检验,结果良好。超声治疗和低强度激光治疗分别在一项研究中进行了检验,结果不尽人意。基于所综述的试验,建议从低成本、以患者为中心的治疗方法开始进行治疗试验,尤其是拉伸、非处方矫形器和患者教育。几篇(但并非全部)所综述的文章表明,定制矫形器对足底筋膜炎的益处大于非处方矫形器。如果这些治疗方法不能提供令人满意的效果,则应考虑使用夜间夹板。基于本综述,不支持使用磁鞋垫治疗足底筋膜炎。大多数研究至少存在一个方法学缺陷,包括样本量不足、高失访率、将多种干预措施与多种干预措施进行比较(因此难以确定每种单独干预措施的效果)以及缺乏长期随访。各研究之间的结局测量方法使用不一致。