Suppr超能文献

医学史上治疗学说的起源、传播与发展——以顺势疗法为例

[The origin, diffusion and development of healing doctrines in medical history--exemplified by homeopathy].

作者信息

Schmidt Josef M

机构信息

Institut für Geschichte der Medizin der Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München, Lessingstrasse 2, D-80336 München.

出版信息

Sudhoffs Arch. 2007;91(1):38-72.

Abstract

As a paradigmatic case study of the origin, spread, and development of medical systems, this paper investigates the 200-years history of homeopathy from different perspectives of medical history. On the basis of new research on Samuel Hahnemann (1755-1843), first, a concise and critical overview on the principles, explanations, and implications of his doctrine is presented. The historical, conceptual, and social background of the founder of homeopathy is then elaborated in terms of history of medicine, science, philosophy, sociology, culture, and ideas, as well as theory of science, theory of communication, and sociology of science. The process of the world wide spread of homeopathy is examined from different points of view, ranging from history of heroes, institutions, professionalisation, politics, economics, religion, and organisations to history of patients, perception, and semiotics. Finally, a comparative approach to the different development and status of homeopathy in different countries results in the extraction of a set of crucial variables, such as charismatic personage, influential patronage, economic sponsorship, political protection, media support, and patients' demand, which might explane a major part of these differences. Eventually, the notorious splits of homeopathy's doctrine suggest the idea that--in analogy to theory of evolution--a variety of concurrent strains (rather than one monolithic block) of a doctrine may prove to be a kind of advantage for survival. In conclusion, acceptance and relevance of medical systems are determined by many factors. Since external ones are usually outweighing internal ones, medical history may offer a broader and more comprehensive understanding of the dynamics of their spread and development than clinical trials and scientific objection alone.

摘要

作为医学体系起源、传播和发展的一个典型案例研究,本文从医学史的不同视角考察了顺势疗法200年的历史。基于对塞缪尔·哈内曼(1755 - 1843)的新研究,首先,对其学说的原理、解释及影响进行了简要且批判性的概述。接着,从医学史、科学史、哲学史、社会学、文化史、思想史以及科学理论、传播理论和科学社会学等方面阐述了顺势疗法创始人的历史、概念和社会背景。从英雄史、机构史、职业化史、政治史、经济史、宗教史、组织史到患者史、认知史和符号学史等不同角度审视了顺势疗法在全球传播的过程。最后,通过对顺势疗法在不同国家的不同发展和地位进行比较分析,提炼出一系列关键变量,如魅力人物、有影响力的赞助、经济资助、政治保护、媒体支持和患者需求等,这些变量或许可以解释这些差异的很大一部分原因。最终,顺势疗法学说臭名昭著的分裂表明,类似于进化论,一种学说的多种并存流派(而非单一整体)可能被证明是一种生存优势。总之,医学体系的接受度和相关性由多种因素决定。由于外部因素通常比内部因素更具影响力,医学史可能比单纯的临床试验和科学异议能更广泛、更全面地理解其传播和发展的动态过程。

文献AI研究员

20分钟写一篇综述,助力文献阅读效率提升50倍。

立即体验

用中文搜PubMed

大模型驱动的PubMed中文搜索引擎

马上搜索

文档翻译

学术文献翻译模型,支持多种主流文档格式。

立即体验