Vandelanotte Corneel, Spathonis Kym M, Eakin Elizabeth G, Owen Neville
Cancer Prevention Research Centre, School of Population Health, The University of Queensland, Australia.
Am J Prev Med. 2007 Jul;33(1):54-64. doi: 10.1016/j.amepre.2007.02.041.
Evidence-based physical activity interventions that can be delivered to large numbers of adults at an acceptable cost are a public health priority; website-delivered programs have this potential. The purpose of this study was to systematically review the research findings and outcomes of website-delivered physical activity interventions and to identify relationships of intervention attributes with behavioral outcomes.
A structured search of PubMed, Medline, PsycInfo, and Web of Science was conducted for intervention studies published up to July 2006. Studies included in the review were those that (1) used websites or e-mail, (2) had physical activity behavior as an outcome measure, (3) had randomized controlled or quasi-experimental designs, (4) targeted adults, and (5) were published in English.
Of the fifteen studies reviewed, improvement in physical activity was reported in eight. Better outcomes were identified when interventions had more than five contacts with participants and when the time to follow-up was short (</=3 months; 60% positive outcomes), compared to medium-term (3-6 months, 50%) and long-term (>6 months, 40%) follow-up. There were no clear associations of outcomes with other intervention attributes.
A little over half of the controlled trials of website-delivered physical activity interventions have reported positive behavioral outcomes. However, intervention effects were short lived, and there was limited evidence of maintenance of physical activity changes. Research is needed to identify elements that can improve behavioral outcomes, the maintenance of change and the engagement and retention of participants; larger and more representative study samples are also needed.
能够以可接受的成本为大量成年人提供的基于证据的体育活动干预措施是公共卫生的重点;通过网站提供的项目具有这种潜力。本研究的目的是系统回顾通过网站提供的体育活动干预措施的研究结果和成果,并确定干预属性与行为结果之间的关系。
对截至2006年7月发表的干预研究在PubMed、Medline、PsycInfo和科学网进行了结构化检索。纳入综述的研究包括:(1)使用网站或电子邮件的;(2)以体育活动行为作为结果指标的;(3)采用随机对照或准实验设计的;(4)针对成年人的;(5)以英文发表的。
在纳入综述的15项研究中,有8项报告了体育活动有所改善。与中期(3至6个月,50%)和长期(>6个月,40%)随访相比,当干预措施与参与者有超过5次接触且随访时间较短(≤3个月;60%为阳性结果)时,可获得更好的结果。结果与其他干预属性之间没有明确的关联。
略超过一半的通过网站提供的体育活动干预措施的对照试验报告了积极的行为结果。然而,干预效果是短暂的,而且体育活动变化维持的证据有限。需要开展研究以确定能够改善行为结果、维持变化以及提高参与者参与度和留存率的因素;还需要更大规模和更具代表性的研究样本。