Rumbold Alice R, Cunningham Joan
Menzies School of Health Research, PO Box 41096, Casuarina, NT, 0811, Australia.
Matern Child Health J. 2008 Jan;12(1):83-100. doi: 10.1007/s10995-007-0216-1. Epub 2007 Jun 19.
To review evaluations of changes in the delivery of antenatal care for Australian Indigenous women and the impact on care utilization and quality, birth outcomes and women's views about care.
Seven databases were searched electronically for articles describing evaluations of antenatal care programs developed for Australian Indigenous women. Manual searches were performed of the publication sections of websites of Australian Government Departments responsible for health and Indigenous affairs.
Evaluations of 10 antenatal care programs were identified. Wide variations were present in the design, quality and reported outcomes of each evaluation. There was a lack of consistency in the findings across all care programs for many outcomes. Modest increases were reported for measures of care utilization, including the proportion of women initiating care in the first trimester and the mean number of antenatal visits overall. For birth outcomes, benefits were reported by some but not all care programs for perinatal mortality, preterm birth, mean birth weight and the proportion of low birth weight infants. Of the four care programs reporting women's views about care, most comments were positive reflections about care, including the use of female staff and the continuity of care providers.
The impact of the antenatal care programs evaluated and published to date remains inconclusive. Limitations arose from the diversity in the design of evaluations and the quality of reported data. This review has highlighted the need for good quality long-term data collection about the health services providing antenatal care for Australian Indigenous women.
回顾对澳大利亚原住民妇女产前护理服务变化的评估,以及这些变化对护理利用和质量、分娩结局及妇女对护理看法的影响。
通过电子检索七个数据库,查找描述为澳大利亚原住民妇女制定的产前护理项目评估的文章。对负责卫生和原住民事务的澳大利亚政府部门网站的出版物板块进行手工检索。
确定了10个产前护理项目的评估。每项评估在设计、质量和报告的结果方面存在很大差异。许多结果在所有护理项目中的研究结果缺乏一致性。护理利用指标有适度增加,包括孕早期开始接受护理的妇女比例和总体产前检查的平均次数。对于分娩结局,一些但并非所有护理项目报告了围产期死亡率、早产、平均出生体重和低出生体重婴儿比例方面的益处。在报告妇女对护理看法的四个护理项目中,大多数评论是对护理的积极反馈,包括使用女性工作人员和护理提供者的连续性。
迄今为止评估和发表的产前护理项目的影响尚无定论。局限性源于评估设计的多样性和报告数据的质量。本综述强调了需要收集有关为澳大利亚原住民妇女提供产前护理的卫生服务的高质量长期数据。