Daly Gillian L, Lei Ying D, Teixeira Camilla, Muir Derek C G, Castillo Luisa E, Wania Frank
Department of Chemistry, University of Toronto at Scarborough, 1265 Military Trail, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
Environ Sci Technol. 2007 Feb 15;41(4):1118-23. doi: 10.1021/es0622709.
In Central America, chemical-intensive tropical agriculture takes place in close proximity to highly valued and biologically diverse ecosystems, yet the potential for atmospheric transport of pesticides from plantations to national parks and other reserves is poorly characterized. The specific meteorological conditions of mountain ranges can lead to contaminant convergence at high altitudes, raising particular concern for montane forest ecosystems downwind from pesticide use areas. Here we show, based on a wide-ranging air and soil sampling campaign across Costa Rica, that soils in some neotropical montane forests indeed display much higher concentrations of currently used pesticides than soils elsewhere in the country. Specifically, elevated concentrations of the fungicide chlorothalonil, the herbicide dacthal, and the insecticide metabolite endosulfan sulfate on volcanoes Barva and Poas, lying directly downwind of the extensive banana plantations of the Caribbean lowland, indicate the occurrence of atmospheric transport and wet deposition of pesticides at high altitudes. Calculations with a contaminant fate model, designed for mountain regions and parametrized to the Costa Rican environment, show that chemicals with a log K(AW) between -3 and -5 have a greater potential for accumulation at high altitudes. This enrichment behavior is quantified by the Mountain Contamination Potential and is sensitive to contaminant degradability. The modeling work supports the hypothesis suggested by the field results that it is enhanced precipitation scavenging at high elevations (caused by lower temperatures and governed by K(AW)) that causes pesticides to accumulate in tropical montane areas. By providing for the first time evidence of significant transfer of currently used pesticides to Central American montane cloud forests, this study highlights the need to evaluate the risk that tropical agricultural practices place on the region's ecological reserves.
在中美洲,化学投入密集型的热带农业与高价值且生物多样性丰富的生态系统毗邻,然而,农药从种植园向国家公园和其他保护区进行大气传输的可能性却鲜有描述。山脉的特定气象条件可能导致污染物在高海拔地区汇聚,这使得人们对农药使用区域下风处的山地森林生态系统尤为担忧。在此,基于在哥斯达黎加开展的广泛空气和土壤采样活动,我们发现,一些新热带山地森林的土壤中目前使用的农药浓度确实远高于该国其他地区的土壤。具体而言,在加勒比低地广阔香蕉种植园的直接下风处,巴尔瓦火山和波阿斯火山上的杀菌剂百菌清、除草剂敌草索以及杀虫剂代谢物硫丹硫酸盐的浓度升高,这表明高海拔地区存在农药的大气传输和湿沉降现象。利用一个针对山区设计并根据哥斯达黎加环境进行参数化的污染物归宿模型进行计算,结果显示,log K(AW) 在 -3 至 -5 之间的化学物质在高海拔地区有更大的积累潜力。这种富集行为通过山地污染潜力进行量化,并且对污染物的降解能力敏感。建模工作支持了实地结果所提出的假设,即高海拔地区增强的降水清除作用(由较低温度引起且受 K(AW) 控制)导致农药在热带山地地区积累。通过首次提供目前使用的农药大量转移至中美洲山地云雾森林的证据,本研究凸显了评估热带农业活动对该地区生态保护区所构成风险的必要性。