Hubbe Mark, Neves Walter A, do Amaral Heleno Licurgo, Guidon Niéde
Instituto de Investigaciones Arqueológicas y Museo-Universidad Católica del Norte, Calle Gustavo LePaige 380, 141-0000 San Pedro de Atacama, Chile.
Am J Phys Anthropol. 2007 Oct;134(2):285-91. doi: 10.1002/ajpa.20668.
The Serra da Capivara National Park in northeastern Brazil is one of the richest archaeological regions in South America. Nonetheless, so far only two paleoindian skeletons have been exhumed from the local rockshelters. The oldest one (9870 +/- 50 BP; CAL 11060 +/- 50), uncovered in Toca dos Coqueiros and known as "Zuzu," represents a rare opportunity to explore the biological relationships of paleoindian groups living in northeastern Brazil. As previously demonstrated, South and Central America Paleoindians present skull morphology distinct from the one found nowadays in Amerindians and similar to Australo-Melanesians. Here we test the hypothesis that Zuzu shows higher morphological affinity with Paleoindians. However, Zuzu is a controversial skeleton since previous osteological assessments have disagreed on several aspects, especially regarding its sex. Thus, we compared Zuzu to males and females independently. Morphological affinities were assessed through clustering of principal components considering 18 worldwide populations and through principal components analysis of the individual dispersion of five key regions for America's settlement. The results obtained do not allow us to refute the hypothesis, expanding the known geographical dispersion of the Paleoindian morphology into northeast Brazil. To contribute to the discussion regarding Zuzu's sex, a new estimation is presented based on visual inspection of cranial and post-cranial markers, complemented by a discriminant analysis of its morphology in relation to the paleoindian sample. The results favor a male classification and are consistent with the mortuary offerings found in the burial, yet do not agree with a molecular determination.
巴西东北部的卡皮瓦拉山国家公园是南美洲最富考古价值的地区之一。尽管如此,到目前为止,仅从当地的岩洞中发掘出两具古印第安人骨骼。最古老的一具(9870±50 BP;校正后为11060±50)在托卡多斯科凯罗斯被发现,名为“祖祖”,它为探索生活在巴西东北部的古印第安人群体之间的生物学关系提供了难得的机会。如先前所示,南美洲和中美洲的古印第安人的头骨形态与现今美洲印第安人的不同,而与澳大利亚 - 美拉尼西亚人相似。在此,我们检验祖祖与古印第安人具有更高形态学相似性的假设。然而,祖祖是一具存在争议的骨骼,因为先前的骨学评估在几个方面存在分歧,尤其是关于其性别。因此,我们分别将祖祖与男性和女性进行比较。通过考虑18个全球人群的主成分聚类以及对美洲定居的五个关键区域个体离散度的主成分分析来评估形态学相似性。所得结果无法让我们反驳该假设,这将古印第安人形态学已知的地理分布范围扩展到了巴西东北部。为推动关于祖祖性别的讨论,基于对头骨和颅后标记的目视检查,并辅以对其与古印第安人样本形态的判别分析,提出了一种新的估计方法。结果支持将其分类为男性,这与墓葬中发现的随葬品相符,但与分子测定结果不一致。