Mets Onno, Spronk Peter E, Binnekade Jan, Stoker Jaap, de Mol Bas A J M, Schultz Marcus J
Department of Intensive Care Medicine, Academic Medical Center, University of Amsterdam, Amsterdam, The Netherlands.
J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 2007 Jul;134(1):139-44. doi: 10.1016/j.jtcvs.2007.02.029.
We sought to determine the effect of elimination of daily routine chest radiographs on chest radiographic practice in cardiothoracic surgery patients in the intensive care unit and the post-intensive care unit ward.
We used a prospective, comparative study design with an intervention in a 28-bed intensive care unit/post-intensive care unit ward (including a 4-bed medium-care unit) in a university hospital. Cardiothoracic surgery patients were admitted to the intensive care unit during a period of 6 months (3 months before intervention and 3 months after intervention). Daily routine chest radiographs in the intensive care unit were eliminated; all chest radiographs required a clinical indication. Routine chest radiographs were not performed in the post-intensive care unit ward, both before and after the intervention.
Before intervention, in the intensive care unit 353 daily routine chest radiographs and 261 on-demand chest radiographs were obtained in 175 patients; after intervention, 275 on-demand chest radiographs were obtained in 163 patients. Before intervention, in the post-intensive care unit ward 413 on-demand chest radiographs were obtained in 167 patients; after intervention, 445 on-demand chest radiographs were obtained in 161 patients. In the intensive care unit the number of chest radiographs per patient day decreased from 1.8 +/- 0.6 to 1.1 +/- 0.6. In the post-intensive care unit ward the number of chest radiographs per patient per day was 0.4 +/- 0.2, both before and after the intervention. Slightly more unexpected abnormalities were found in the on-demand chest radiographs after the intervention. No negative influence on chest radiography timing, length of stay in the intensive care unit and hospital, and readmission rate was seen.
Elimination of daily routine chest radiographs led to a decrease of the total number of chest radiographs obtained per patient per day in the intensive care unit and did not change chest radiography practice in the post-intensive care unit ward.
我们试图确定取消每日常规胸部X光检查对重症监护病房及重症监护病房后病房心胸外科手术患者胸部X光检查实践的影响。
我们采用前瞻性对照研究设计,在一所大学医院的一个拥有28张床位的重症监护病房/重症监护病房后病房(包括一个拥有4张床位的中级护理病房)进行干预。心胸外科手术患者在6个月期间入住重症监护病房(干预前3个月和干预后3个月)。取消了重症监护病房的每日常规胸部X光检查;所有胸部X光检查均需有临床指征。干预前后,重症监护病房后病房均未进行常规胸部X光检查。
干预前,在重症监护病房,175例患者共进行了353次每日常规胸部X光检查和261次按需胸部X光检查;干预后,163例患者共进行了275次按需胸部X光检查。干预前,在重症监护病房后病房,167例患者共进行了413次按需胸部X光检查;干预后,161例患者共进行了445次按需胸部X光检查。在重症监护病房,每日每位患者的胸部X光检查次数从1.8±0.6降至1.1±0.6。在重症监护病房后病房,干预前后每日每位患者的胸部X光检查次数均为0.4±0.2。干预后按需胸部X光检查中发现的意外异常略多。未发现对胸部X光检查时机、重症监护病房及医院住院时间和再入院率有负面影响。
取消每日常规胸部X光检查导致重症监护病房每位患者每日获得的胸部X光检查总数减少,且未改变重症监护病房后病房的胸部X光检查实践。