Bharadwaj Sandeep N, Smith Ben, Vitello Dominic, Nisivaco Sarah M, Saatee Siavosh, Allen Bradley D, Malaisrie S Christopher
Division of Cardiac Surgery, Department of Surgery, Northwestern University Feinberg School of Medicine, Chicago, Illinois.
Department of Radiology, Northwestern University Feinberg School of Medicine, Chicago, Illinois.
Ann Thorac Surg Short Rep. 2023 Apr 5;1(3):526-529. doi: 10.1016/j.atssr.2023.03.016. eCollection 2023 Sep.
A routine chest radiograph (CXR) is frequently incorporated into postoperative clinical pathways. Whereas prior studies evaluated CXR use for specific indications, overall CXR "stewardship" within cardiothoracic surgery remains undescribed. We characterized CXR use within a cardiothoracic intensive care unit (ICU) and quantified X-ray-driven changes in patient management.
All CXRs performed during 3 months in the cardiothoracic ICU of an academic 900-bed tertiary care hospital were retrospectively reviewed. Attending radiologist CXR reports and clinical history from ordering providers were manually reviewed to classify CXRs as indicated or not indicated by American College of Radiology (ACR) Appropriateness Criteria. Multiple resident-level providers further reviewed CXRs to determine whether the image demonstrated any actionable or unexpected findings.
Between October 1, 2021, and January 3, 2022, 1273 CXRs were performed on adult cardiac and general thoracic surgery patients; the most common indication was routine daily (55.9%), followed by support device monitoring (12.4%) and new ICU transfer (10.4%). Only 34.3% of performed CXRs met ACR Appropriateness Criteria; 65.7% did not ( = .002). Only 3.8% of not indicated CXRs had actionable or significant findings vs 13.0% of indicated CXRs ( = .02). Of the 32 not indicated CXRs with actionable findings, 37.5% recommended endotracheal tube repositioning and 28.1% recommended other line or tube repositioning.
CXRs are overused in the cardiothoracic ICU according to ACR Appropriateness Criteria. CXRs performed outside these guidelines have significantly fewer actionable or meaningful findings. Optimizing CXR use can improve resource utilization and efficiency in care of cardiothoracic surgical patients.
常规胸部X线片(CXR)常被纳入术后临床路径。尽管先前的研究评估了CXR用于特定指征的情况,但心胸外科手术中整体的CXR“管理”情况仍未得到描述。我们对心胸重症监护病房(ICU)内CXR的使用情况进行了描述,并量化了X线驱动的患者管理变化。
对一家拥有900张床位的学术型三级医院心胸ICU在3个月内进行的所有CXR进行回顾性审查。人工查阅主治放射科医生的CXR报告和开单医生的临床病史,根据美国放射学会(ACR)适宜性标准将CXR分类为有指征或无指征。多名住院医师级别的医生进一步审查CXR,以确定图像是否显示出任何可采取行动的或意外的发现。
在2021年10月1日至2022年1月3日期间,对成人心脏和普通胸外科手术患者进行了1273次CXR检查;最常见的指征是日常常规检查(55.9%),其次是支持设备监测(12.4%)和新转入ICU(10.4%)。只有34.3%的CXR检查符合ACR适宜性标准;65.7%不符合(P = .002)。无指征的CXR检查中只有3.8%有可采取行动的或重大的发现,而有指征的CXR检查中这一比例为13.0%(P = .02)。在32次有可采取行动发现的无指征CXR检查中,37.5%建议重新定位气管插管,28.1%建议重新定位其他线路或导管。
根据ACR适宜性标准,心胸ICU中CXR存在过度使用的情况。在这些指南之外进行的CXR检查,其可采取行动的或有意义的发现明显较少。优化CXR的使用可以提高心胸外科手术患者护理中的资源利用和效率。