Hays Sarah-Jane, Murphy Glynis H, Langdon Peter E, Rose David, Reed Tracy
University of Kent, Canterbury, UK.
J Intellect Dev Disabil. 2007 Jun;32(2):106-16. doi: 10.1080/13668250701413715.
Men with intellectual disability (ID) and sexually abusive behaviour are a disempowered and marginalised group. Nevertheless, as service users, they can be consulted and involved in a variety of different ways, including ascertaining their views of the services they receive.
A group of 16 men with ID and sexually abusive behaviour were interviewed to ascertain their views approximately 2 months after completing a 1-year group cognitive behavioural treatment (CBT) for sexual offending. Two raters independently reviewed interview transcripts and participant responses were summarised.
The most salient components of treatment recalled by participants were: sex education; legal and illegal behaviours and their consequences; and discussions about specific sexual assaults. Only 3 of the 16 participants stated that they had problems with sexual offending, and only 1 identified that he had learnt about victim empathy, although this is an important component of treatment. Having support, the knowledge that they had the same problems as other group members, and talking through problems, were appreciated as some of the "best things" about the group, while the "worst things" were generally person-specific. Participants had mixed views on talking about their own offences during group sessions and, overall, viewed the experience as difficult but helpful.
Valuable insights into the aspects of treatment that group members found useful were explored. Such insights are often not captured by studies that assess the efficacy of treatment models using treatment-specific measures only, and these are important in defining the quality of services provided.
患有智力障碍(ID)且有性侵犯行为的男性是一个弱势且被边缘化的群体。然而,作为服务使用者,可以通过多种不同方式咨询并让他们参与其中,包括了解他们对所接受服务的看法。
对一组16名患有智力障碍且有性侵犯行为的男性进行了访谈,以了解他们在完成为期1年的针对性犯罪的团体认知行为疗法(CBT)约2个月后的看法。两名评估者独立审查访谈记录并总结参与者的回答。
参与者回忆起的治疗中最显著的部分是:性教育;合法与非法行为及其后果;以及关于特定性侵犯的讨论。16名参与者中只有3人表示他们在性犯罪方面存在问题,只有1人指出他了解到了对受害者的同理心,尽管这是治疗的一个重要组成部分。获得支持、知道自己与其他团体成员有相同的问题以及通过讨论解决问题,被视为该团体的一些“最好的事情”,而“最糟糕的事情”通常因人而异。参与者对于在团体会议中谈论自己的罪行看法不一,总体而言,他们认为这段经历虽艰难但有帮助。
探讨了关于团体成员认为有用的治疗方面的宝贵见解。仅使用特定于治疗的措施来评估治疗模式效果的研究往往无法捕捉到这些见解,而这些见解对于界定所提供服务的质量很重要。