Murphy Glynis, Powell Simon, Guzman Ana-Maria, Hays Sarah-Jane
Tizard Centre, University of Kent, Canterbury, Kent, UK.
J Intellect Disabil Res. 2007 Nov;51(Pt 11):902-12. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2788.2007.00990.x.
Cognitive-behaviour therapy (CBT) seems to be becoming the treatment of choice for non-disabled sex offenders. Nevertheless, there have been relatively few evaluations of such treatment for men with intellectual disabilities (ID) and sexually abusive behaviour.
A pilot study providing CBT for two groups of men with ID is described. Measures of change in sexual knowledge, victim empathy and cognitive distortions were collected, together with a log of further sexually abusive behaviour.
Fifteen men were offered treatment but some dropped out and some declined to take part in the research. The results for the eight men who consented to the research and completed treatment showed significant positive changes in sexual knowledge and victim empathy (two men completed both groups, making 10 sets of data in all). Cognitive distortions showed significant change on only one of the two measures. Some men showed further sexually abusive behaviour either during or after the treatment group (all had been previously diagnosed as on the autistic spectrum).
There is a need for a larger multi-site trial of treatment with a broad set of measures and the ability to analyse who benefits from such treatments and who does not.
认知行为疗法(CBT)似乎正成为非残疾性犯罪者的首选治疗方法。然而,针对有智力障碍(ID)和性侵犯行为的男性进行此类治疗的评估相对较少。
描述了一项为两组有智力障碍的男性提供认知行为疗法的试点研究。收集了性知识、对受害者的同理心和认知扭曲方面的变化测量数据,以及进一步性侵犯行为的记录。
15名男性接受了治疗,但一些人退出,一些人拒绝参与研究。同意参与研究并完成治疗的8名男性的结果显示,性知识和对受害者的同理心有显著的积极变化(两名男性完成了两组治疗,总共得到10组数据)。认知扭曲仅在两项测量中的一项上显示出显著变化。一些男性在治疗组期间或之后出现了进一步的性侵犯行为(所有人之前都被诊断为患有自闭症谱系障碍)。
需要进行一项更大规模的多地点试验,采用广泛的测量方法,并能够分析谁能从此类治疗中受益,谁不能。