Thomas L H, Bond S
University of Newcastle upon Tyne, Centre for Health Services Research, U.K.
Int J Nurs Stud. 1991;28(4):291-314. doi: 10.1016/0020-7489(91)90057-a.
Using primary nursing as a 'case study', this paper reviews research literature which attempts to measure the effectiveness of a mode of nursing using outcome measures. Previous research, it is argued, is hampered by a lack of conceptualization of structure and process and inadequate research design, with consequent uncertain findings. A shift in emphasis is suggested from an evaluation of global concepts, such as primary nursing, to an identification of the features of structures and processes of nursing care which interrelate with patient and nurse outcomes. For this purpose, multivariate research design and investment in methodological research are recommended.
本文以责任制护理作为“案例研究”,回顾了试图运用结果指标来衡量一种护理模式有效性的研究文献。有人认为,以往的研究因缺乏对结构和过程的概念化以及研究设计不充分而受到阻碍,结果也因此不确定。建议重点从对诸如责任制护理等整体概念的评估,转向识别与患者和护士结果相关的护理结构和过程的特征。为此,推荐采用多变量研究设计并投入方法学研究。