Drasch Gustav, Dahlmann Felicitas, von Meyer Ludwig, Roider Gabriele, Eisenmenger Wolfgang
Institute of Forensic Medicine, Ludwig-Maximilians-University, NuBbaumstr. 26, D 80336 Munich, Germany.
Int J Legal Med. 2008 Mar;122(2):115-21. doi: 10.1007/s00414-007-0178-2. Epub 2007 Jul 6.
From each case of suicide and drug-related death autopsied in the Institute of Forensic Medicine, Munich during the years 2001--2005, a toxicological investigation on anti-depressants (AD) was performed. In 180 suicides and 72 narcotic drug death cases, ADs were detected: 4 different classic tricyclic anti-depressants (TCAs), 6 other non-selective monoamine re-uptake inhibitors (NSMRIs), 5 selective serotonin re-uptake inhibitors (SSRIs) and 3 other ADs. The suicides were grouped further according to the type of suicide (violent or non-violent). The prescription frequency of the ADs in Germany, expressed as the defined daily dosages (DDDs), during the investigated years served for comparison. There were serious differences in the frequency of different ADs regarding to the manner of suicide. In cases associated with doxepin and trimipramine, non-violent suicides were distinctly over-represented, as in cases in which the drug itself was responsible for the death as in cases of non-violent suicides in other manners. In contrast, in cases with citalopram or opipramol, violent forms of suicides were significantly over-represented. For amitriptyline, the ratio was approximately balanced. For the remainder of the ADs, the case numbers were too low for a valid evaluation. The different frequency distributions of the ADs, associated with violent and non-violent suicides may be explained by their different pharmacological active profiles and the different lethality of overdoses of the different ADs. There was no indication at all for a special suicidal problem of SSRIs in juveniles. Amongst 1,127 suicides within 5 years, in an area with approximately 5 million people, the youngest suicide victim with SSRIs was 28 years old. In drug death cases, citalopram was obviously over-represented.
2001年至2005年期间,对慕尼黑法医学研究所尸检的每一例自杀和药物相关死亡病例都进行了抗抑郁药(AD)的毒理学调查。在180例自杀病例和72例麻醉药品死亡病例中,检测到了AD:4种不同的经典三环类抗抑郁药(TCA)、6种其他非选择性单胺再摄取抑制剂(NSMRI)、5种选择性5-羟色胺再摄取抑制剂(SSRI)和3种其他AD。自杀病例根据自杀类型(暴力或非暴力)进一步分组。调查年份期间德国AD的处方频率以限定日剂量(DDD)表示,用于比较。不同AD的频率在自杀方式方面存在严重差异。在与多塞平和曲米帕明相关的病例中,非暴力自杀明显占比过高,就像药物本身导致死亡的病例以及其他方式的非暴力自杀病例一样。相比之下,在使用西酞普兰或奥匹哌醇的病例中,暴力自杀形式明显占比过高。对于阿米替林,比例大致平衡。对于其余的AD,病例数太少,无法进行有效评估。与暴力和非暴力自杀相关的AD的不同频率分布可能由它们不同的药理活性特征以及不同AD过量服用的不同致死率来解释。完全没有迹象表明青少年中存在SSRI的特殊自杀问题。在5年内约500万人居住地区的1127例自杀病例中,使用SSRI的最年轻自杀受害者为28岁。在药物死亡病例中,西酞普兰明显占比过高。