Jensen Søren Krogh, Lauridsen Charlotte
Department of Animal Health, Welfare and Nutrition, Faculty of Agricultural Sciences, University of Aarhus, DK-8830 Tjele, Denmark.
Vitam Horm. 2007;76:281-308. doi: 10.1016/S0083-6729(07)76010-7.
Vitamin E comprises a group of compounds possessing vitamin E activity. alpha-Tocopherol is the compound demonstrating the highest vitamin E activity, which is available both in its natural form as RRR-alpha-tocopherol isolated from plant sources, but more common as synthetically manufactured all-rac-alpha-tocopherol. Synthetic all-rac-alpha-tocopherol consists of a racemic mixture of all eight possible stereoisomers. Assessing the correct biological activity in form of bioavailability and biopotency has been a great challenge during many years as it is difficult to measure clinical endpoints in larger animals than rats and poultry. Thus, the biological effects in focus are resorption of fetuses, testicular degeneration, muscle dystrophy, anemia, encephalomalacia, and in recent years the influence of vitamin E on the immune system are the most important clinical markers of interest. For humans and animals, only different biomarkers or surrogate markers of bioactivity have been measured. In studies with rats, a good consistency between the classical resorption-gestation test and the bioavailability of the individual stereoisomers in fluids and tissues has been shown. For humans and other animals, only different biomarkers or surrogate markers of bioactivity have been measured, and due to the lack of good biological markers for bioactivities, bioavailability is often used as one of the surrogate markers for bioactivities with those limitations this must give. Therefore, a relatively simple analytical method, which allows analysis of the individual stereoisomers of alpha-tocopherol, is an important tool in order to quantify relative bioavailability of the individual stereoisomers. The analytical method presented here allows the quantification of total tocopherol content and composition by normal phase HPLC and subsequent separation of the stereoisomers of alpha-tocopherol as methyl ethers by chiral HPLC. Using this method, the alpha-tocopherol stereoisomers are separated into five peaks. The first peak consists of the four 2S isomers (SSS-, SSR-, SRR-, SRS-), the second peak consists of RSS-, the third peak consists of RRS-, the fourth peak consists of RRR-, and the fifth peak consists of RSR-alpha-tocopherol. The discussion on the bioavailability of RRR- and all-rac-alpha-tocopheryl acetate has primarily been based on human and animal studies using deuterium-labeled forms, whereby a higher biopotency of 2:1 (of RRR: all-rac) has been demonstrated, differing from the accepted biopotency ratio of 1.36:1. In agreement with previous studies, the 2S-forms exert very little importance for the vitamin E activity due to their limited bioavailability. We find notable differences between animal species with regard to the biodiscrimination between the 2R-forms. Especially, cows preferentially transfer RRR- alpha-tocopherol into the milk and blood system. The distribution of the stereoisomer forms varies from tissue to tissue, and in some cases, higher levels of the synthetic 2R-forms than of the RRR-form are obtained, for example, for rats. However, the biodiscrimination of the stereoisomers forms is influenced by other factors such as age, dietary levels, and time after dosage. More focus should be given on the bioactivity of the individual 2R-forms rather than just the comparison between RRR- and all-rac-alpha-tocopheryl acetate.
维生素E由一组具有维生素E活性的化合物组成。α-生育酚是表现出最高维生素E活性的化合物,它既有从植物来源分离得到的天然形式RRR-α-生育酚,也有更常见的合成制备的消旋-α-生育酚。合成的消旋-α-生育酚由所有八种可能的立体异构体的外消旋混合物组成。多年来,以生物利用度和生物活性形式评估正确的生物活性一直是一项巨大挑战,因为在比大鼠和家禽更大的动物中测量临床终点很困难。因此,关注的生物学效应包括胎儿吸收、睾丸退化、肌肉萎缩、贫血、脑软化,近年来维生素E对免疫系统的影响是最重要的临床关注指标。对于人类和动物,仅测量了不同的生物标志物或生物活性替代标志物。在大鼠研究中,经典的吸收-妊娠试验与各立体异构体在体液和组织中的生物利用度之间已显示出良好的一致性。对于人类和其他动物,仅测量了不同的生物标志物或生物活性替代标志物,并且由于缺乏用于生物活性的良好生物标志物,生物利用度常被用作生物活性的替代标志物之一,但必然存在这些局限性。因此,一种相对简单的分析方法,能够分析α-生育酚的各个立体异构体,是量化各立体异构体相对生物利用度的重要工具。这里介绍的分析方法允许通过正相高效液相色谱法(HPLC)定量总生育酚含量和组成,随后通过手性HPLC将α-生育酚的立体异构体分离为甲基醚。使用这种方法,α-生育酚立体异构体被分离为五个峰。第一个峰由四种2S异构体(SSS-、SSR-、SRR-、SRS-)组成,第二个峰由RSS-组成,第三个峰由RRS-组成,第四个峰由RRR-组成,第五个峰由RSR-α-生育酚组成。关于RRR-和消旋-α-生育酚醋酸酯生物利用度的讨论主要基于使用氘标记形式的人类和动物研究,由此证明了2:1(RRR:消旋)的更高生物活性,这与公认的1.36:1的生物活性比不同。与先前的研究一致,2S形式由于其有限的生物利用度,对维生素E活性的影响很小。我们发现在动物物种之间,2R形式的生物辨别存在显著差异。特别是,奶牛优先将RRR-α-生育酚转移到乳汁和血液系统中。立体异构体形式的分布因组织而异,在某些情况下,例如对于大鼠,合成的2R形式的水平高于RRR形式。然而,立体异构体形式的生物辨别受其他因素影响,如年龄、饮食水平和给药后的时间。应该更多地关注各个2R形式的生物活性,而不仅仅是RRR-和消旋-α-生育酚醋酸酯之间的比较。