Hosker G, Cody J D, Norton C C
St Mary's Hospital, Warrell Unit, Hathersage Road, Manchester, UK M13 OJH.
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2007 Jul 18;2007(3):CD001310. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD001310.pub2.
Faecal incontinence is a particularly embarrassing and distressing condition with significant medical, social and economic implications. Electrical stimulation has been used with apparent success in the treatment of faecal incontinence. However, standards of treatment are still lacking and the magnitude of alleged benefits has yet to be established.
To determine the effects of electrical stimulation for the treatment of faecal incontinence in adults.
We searched the Cochrane Incontinence Group Specialised Trials Register (searched 13 March 2007) and reference lists of potentially eligible articles.
All randomised or quasi-randomised trials evaluating electrical stimulation in adults with faecal incontinence.
Two reviewers assessed the methodological quality of potentially eligible trials and independently extracted data from the included trials. A wide range of outcome measures were considered.
Four eligible trials with 260 participants were identified. Findings from one trial suggest that electrical stimulation with anal biofeedback and exercises provides more short-term benefits than vaginal biofeedback and exercises for women with obstetric-related faecal incontinence. Another study found contradictory results, with no added benefit from electrical stimulation over biofeedback and exercises alone. Although all trials report that patient's symptoms are generally improved, it is not clear that this is the effect of electrical stimulation. No further conclusions could be drawn from the data available.
AUTHORS' CONCLUSIONS: At present, there are insufficient data to allow reliable conclusions to be drawn on the effects of electrical stimulation in the management of faecal incontinence. There is a suggestion that electrical stimulation may have a therapeutic effect, but this is not certain. Larger, more generalisable trials are needed.
大便失禁是一种特别令人尴尬和苦恼的病症,具有重大的医学、社会和经济影响。电刺激已被用于治疗大便失禁,且取得了明显成效。然而,治疗标准仍然缺失,所谓的益处程度也尚未确定。
确定电刺激对治疗成人大便失禁的效果。
我们检索了Cochrane尿失禁组专业试验注册库(检索时间为2007年3月13日)以及潜在合格文章的参考文献列表。
所有评估电刺激治疗成人大便失禁的随机或半随机试验。
两名评审员评估了潜在合格试验的方法学质量,并独立从纳入试验中提取数据。考虑了广泛的结局指标。
共识别出4项合格试验,涉及260名参与者。一项试验的结果表明,对于患有产科相关大便失禁的女性,肛门生物反馈和锻炼结合电刺激比阴道生物反馈和锻炼能带来更多短期益处。另一项研究得出了相互矛盾的结果,即电刺激相比单纯的生物反馈和锻炼并无额外益处。尽管所有试验均报告患者症状总体有所改善,但尚不清楚这是否是电刺激的效果。根据现有数据无法得出进一步结论。
目前,尚无足够数据就电刺激在大便失禁管理中的效果得出可靠结论。有迹象表明电刺激可能具有治疗作用,但并不确定。需要开展规模更大、更具普遍性的试验。