Magnotti Louis J, Weinberg Jordan A, Schroeppel Thomas J, Savage Stephanie A, Fischer Peter E, Bee Tiffany K, Maish George O, Minard Gayle, Zarzaur Ben L, Croce Martin A, Fabian Timothy C
Department of Surgery, University of Tennessee Health Science Center, Memphis, Tennessee 38163, USA.
Am Surg. 2007 Jun;73(6):569-72; discussion 572-3.
The use of serial chest radiographs (CXRs) to evaluate patients with penetrating thoracic trauma is common practice. However, the time interval between these studies and the duration of observation remains uncertain. The purpose of this study was to evaluate whether a noncontrast chest CT is as reliable as a 6-hour CXR for detecting delayed pneumothorax (PTX) after penetrating thoracic trauma. Hemodynamically stable patients with isolated penetrating thoracic trauma were prospectively evaluated with a CXR and a noncontrast chest CT. If there was no PTX or hemothorax, or a finding that did not require immediate intervention, a 6-hour CXR was obtained. Findings were treated as clinically indicated and patients were discharged if all three studies were negative. One hundred eighteen patients were evaluated (89 stab wounds and 29 gunshot wounds). All initial CXRs were negative. CT identified six PTXs and one hemothorax. Two patients required operative intervention. There were no delayed findings on CXR provided the CT was negative. The mean time to CT and before disposition was 19 minutes and 8 hours, respectively, with a potential decrease in charges of $313.32 per patient. The use of serial CXRs provided no additional information that was not available on the initial chest CT, allowing for expedited discharge, decompressing overcrowded emergency areas, and reducing the number of patients leaving before completion of their work-up.
使用系列胸部X线片(CXR)评估穿透性胸部创伤患者是常见的做法。然而,这些检查之间的时间间隔以及观察持续时间仍不确定。本研究的目的是评估非增强胸部CT在检测穿透性胸部创伤后延迟性气胸(PTX)方面是否与6小时胸部X线片一样可靠。对血流动力学稳定的孤立性穿透性胸部创伤患者进行前瞻性CXR和非增强胸部CT评估。如果没有PTX或血胸,或发现不需要立即干预的情况,则进行6小时胸部X线片检查。根据临床指征进行处理,如果所有三项检查均为阴性,则患者出院。共评估了118例患者(89例刺伤和29例枪伤)。所有初始胸部X线片均为阴性。CT发现6例PTX和1例血胸。2例患者需要手术干预。如果CT为阴性,则胸部X线片没有延迟发现。CT检查和出院前的平均时间分别为19分钟和8小时,每位患者的费用可能降低313.32美元。使用系列胸部X线片没有提供初始胸部CT无法获得的额外信息,从而可以加快出院速度,缓解急诊区域的拥挤状况,并减少在检查完成前离开的患者数量。