Sonnex C, Vrotsou K
Department of GU Medicine, Addenbrookes Hospital, Hills Road, Cambridge, UK.
Int J STD AIDS. 2007 Aug;18(8):531-7. doi: 10.1258/095646207781439711.
To determine whether an educational event can affect treatment choice for ano-genital warts, genitourinary medicine clinicians attending a wart management lecture were shown 14 photographs of genital warts of differing morphology at different sites and asked to choose their preferred method of treatment. Study questionnaires were completed pre-lecture and repeated after the lecture and discussion. Podophyllin was chosen significantly less frequently and cryotherapy more frequently post-lecture for certain wart types. Podophyllotoxin was favoured for multiple small penile and posterior fourchette warts, whereas imiquimod was chosen predominantly for large or bulky lesions. Trichloracetic acid was infrequently chosen as a treatment option (<6% of respondents). This study has shown that clinicians attending a lecture on the management of ano-genital warts do change their treatment choice for certain clinical scenarios. Whether opting for a particular treatment in a lecture setting translates to altered practice in the clinical setting requires further study.
为了确定一次教育活动是否会影响肛门生殖器疣的治疗选择,我们让参加疣管理讲座的泌尿生殖医学临床医生观看了14张不同部位、形态各异的生殖器疣照片,并要求他们选择自己偏爱的治疗方法。研究问卷在讲座前完成,并在讲座及讨论后再次填写。对于某些疣类型,讲座后选择鬼臼树脂的频率显著降低,而选择冷冻疗法的频率更高。鬼臼毒素更适用于多个小的阴茎疣和后阴唇系带疣,而咪喹莫特主要用于大的或体积较大的病变。三氯乙酸很少被选为治疗选项(<6%的受访者)。这项研究表明,参加肛门生殖器疣管理讲座的临床医生在某些临床情况下确实会改变他们的治疗选择。在讲座环境中选择特定治疗方法是否会转化为临床环境中的实际改变,还需要进一步研究。