Robinson Jason D, Cinciripini Paul M, Carter Brain L, Lam Cho Y, Wetter David W
Department of Behavioral Science, University of Texas M. D. Anderson Cancer Center, Houston, TX 77230, USA.
Exp Clin Psychopharmacol. 2007 Aug;15(4):390-9. doi: 10.1037/1064-1297.15.4.390.
Negative affect reduction has been postulated to be a key feature of cigarette smoking. In the present study, facial electromyography (EMG), heart rate (HR), and skin conductance response (SCR) were used to evaluate the affective significance of acute nicotine administration and overnight withdrawal. Smokers (N = 115) attended four 90-min laboratory assessment sessions scheduled approximately 3 days apart. The sessions provided a complete crossing of 2 prelaboratory deprivation conditions (12-hr deprived vs. nondeprived) with 2 drug conditions (nicotine vs. placebo nasal spray). During each session, smokers viewed affective slides while facial EMG, HR, and SCR were recorded. Results indicated that for women, nicotine nasal spray resulted in lower corrugator EMG activity during both smoking-deprived and nondeprived sessions, compared with placebo. However, nondeprived women also showed an increase in zygomaticus EMG when given nicotine compared with placebo spray, whereas smoking-deprived women demonstrated a decrease in the zygomaticus response to nicotine compared with placebo. With men, nicotine also appeared to lower corrugator during deprivation, but not nondeprivation, compared with placebo spray, though the contrast only approached significance. With zygomaticus EMG, nicotine spray decreased men's zygomaticus responding during nondeprivation but not during deprivation, compared with placebo spray. The HR results reflected the stimulatory properties of the drug rather than nicotine's affective properties, whereas SCR was unresponsive to our experimental manipulations. The corrugator EMG results support negative reinforcement models of smoking that postulate that acute nicotine use reduces withdrawal-driven negative affect.
减少负面情绪被假定为吸烟的一个关键特征。在本研究中,面部肌电图(EMG)、心率(HR)和皮肤电导反应(SCR)被用于评估急性尼古丁给药和过夜戒断的情感意义。吸烟者(N = 115)参加了四个时长90分钟的实验室评估环节,各环节间隔约3天。这些环节实现了2种实验室前剥夺条件(12小时剥夺与未剥夺)与2种药物条件(尼古丁与安慰剂鼻喷雾剂)的完全交叉。在每个环节中,吸烟者观看情感幻灯片的同时记录面部EMG、HR和SCR。结果表明,对于女性而言,与安慰剂相比,尼古丁鼻喷雾剂在吸烟剥夺和未剥夺环节中均导致皱眉肌EMG活动降低。然而,与安慰剂喷雾剂相比,未被剥夺吸烟机会的女性在使用尼古丁时颧肌EMG也有所增加,而被剥夺吸烟机会的女性与安慰剂相比,对尼古丁的颧肌反应降低。对于男性,与安慰剂喷雾剂相比,尼古丁在剥夺期间似乎也会降低皱眉肌活动,但在未剥夺期间则不然,尽管这种对比仅接近显著水平。与安慰剂喷雾剂相比,使用尼古丁喷雾剂时,男性在未剥夺期间颧肌反应降低,但在剥夺期间则没有。心率结果反映了药物的刺激特性而非尼古丁的情感特性,而皮肤电导反应对我们的实验操作没有反应。皱眉肌EMG结果支持吸烟的负强化模型,该模型假定急性尼古丁使用可减少戒断驱动的负面情绪。