Ghalib Hashim, Modabber Farrokh
Centre for Research and Training in Skin Diseases and Leprosy, Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran.
Kinetoplastid Biol Dis. 2007 Aug 17;6:7. doi: 10.1186/1475-9292-6-7.
Post kala azar dermal leishmaniasis (PKDL) is a disease that appears after treatment of visceral leishmaniasis (VL). The highest incidence of PKDL in the world is in Sudan. Many patients heal spontaneously within 6 months but those who don't are difficult to treat, often requiring months of daily injections. These patients harbour parasite in their skin and are believed to be a source of infection and possibly epidemics. Present treatment modalities of PKDL are inadequate and impractical due to cost, duration of treatment required and side effects. New approach for treatment of PKDL is required. A joint meeting of the UNICEF/UNDP/World Bank/WHO Special Programme for research and training in Tropical Disease (TDR) and the Infectious Disease Research Institute (IDRI) Seattle, USA was held to review the progress of therapeutic vaccines and plan the development of treatment modalities for PKDL.
The history of leishmaniasis vaccine development for prophylaxis and therapy was reviewed. Other than previous infection - simulated by inoculation of live Leishmania as a vaccine (leishmanization), none of the preparations of killed parasite with or without adjuvants have shown significant prophylactic efficacy. Killed L. major absorbed with alum and mixed with BCG remains to be tested as a prophylactic vaccine.
Killed parasite preparations i.e. L. mexicana mixed with BCG and L. amazonensis (combined with low dose of antimonial), have shown efficacy in immunotherapy and immuno-chemotherapy, respectively. In addition combined full antimonial plus alum-absorbed autoclaved L. major vaccine has been shown to significantly improve therapy of refractory PKDL patients. These are all crude preparations of parasites and are difficult to define and standardize. However, there is now a new, second generation vaccine, Leish-111f + MPL-SE, composed of a recombinant protein comprising three leishmanial antigens and a defined adjuvant in clinical development.
Immuno-chemotherapy has the potential of becoming a practical and affordable treatment modality for PKDL and other forms of leishmaniasis. The encouraging results with alum-autoclaved L. major + antimonial should be pursued. However, before further trials, availability of the vaccine and its production under Good Manufacturing Product, hence quality control must be assured. Following satisfactory safety profile of Leish-111f+MPL-SE, clinical trials using this vaccine initially with antimonials should be initiated. Similarly immunotherapy of VL should be considered with the view to controlling development of PKDL. Some immunological studies are required prior to initiation of immunotherapy in VL patients.
黑热病后皮肤利什曼病(PKDL)是一种在内脏利什曼病(VL)治疗后出现的疾病。世界上PKDL发病率最高的地区是苏丹。许多患者在6个月内可自愈,但未自愈的患者治疗困难,通常需要数月每日注射治疗。这些患者皮肤中携带寄生虫,被认为是感染源,甚至可能引发疫情。由于成本、所需治疗时间和副作用等因素,目前PKDL的治疗方式并不充分且不实用。因此需要新的PKDL治疗方法。联合国儿童基金会/联合国开发计划署/世界银行/世界卫生组织热带病研究和培训特别规划署(TDR)与美国西雅图传染病研究所(IDRI)召开了联席会议,以审查治疗性疫苗的进展情况,并规划PKDL治疗方式的研发。
回顾了利什曼病预防性和治疗性疫苗的研发历史。除了通过接种活利什曼原虫作为疫苗模拟既往感染(利什曼化)外,无论是否添加佐剂的死寄生虫制剂均未显示出显著的预防效果。用明矾吸附并与卡介苗混合的死硕大利什曼原虫作为预防性疫苗仍有待测试。
死寄生虫制剂,即与卡介苗混合的墨西哥利什曼原虫和亚马逊利什曼原虫(联合低剂量锑剂),分别在免疫治疗和免疫化疗中显示出疗效。此外,联合全量锑剂加明矾吸附的高压灭菌硕大利什曼原虫疫苗已被证明可显著改善难治性PKDL患者的治疗效果。这些都是寄生虫的粗制制剂,难以定义和标准化。然而,现在有一种新的第二代疫苗Leish-111f + MPL-SE正在进行临床开发,它由包含三种利什曼原虫抗原的重组蛋白和一种特定佐剂组成。
免疫化疗有可能成为PKDL和其他形式利什曼病实用且经济的治疗方式。应继续研究明矾高压灭菌硕大利什曼原虫+锑剂所取得的令人鼓舞的结果。然而,在进一步试验之前,必须确保疫苗的可获得性及其按照药品生产质量管理规范生产,从而保证质量控制。在Leish-111f+MPL-SE的安全性得到满意结果后,应首先使用该疫苗联合锑剂开展临床试验。同样,应考虑对VL进行免疫治疗,以控制PKDL的发展。在对VL患者开始免疫治疗之前,需要进行一些免疫学研究。