Revel Marie-Pierre, Triki Rached, Chatellier Gilles, Couchon Sophie, Haddad Nathalie, Hernigou Anne, Danel Claire, Frija Guy
Assistance Publique des Hôpitaux de Paris, and Université Paris Descartes, France.
Radiology. 2007 Sep;244(3):875-82. doi: 10.1148/radiol.2443060846.
To retrospectively determine sensitivity and specificity of four findings for distinguishing pulmonary infarction from other causes of peripheral pulmonary consolidations on multidetector computed tomographic (CT) images, with other CT and clinical findings as reference.
Institutional review board approved the study and waived informed consent. Three independent radiologists blindly analyzed selected multisection CT images of 50 pulmonary infarctions-not showing direct arterial signs of pulmonary embolism-and 100 peripheral consolidations of other origins. Readers analyzed four findings: triangular shape, vessel sign (defined as presence of an enlarged vessel at the apex of consolidation), central lucencies, and air bronchograms. Interobserver agreement; frequency on CT images with and without infarct; and sensitivity, specificity, and positive likelihood ratio (LR) for diagnosis of pulmonary infarction were assessed for each finding.
One hundred fifty peripheral consolidations were analyzed in 134 (75 men, 59 women) patients (mean age, 55.9 years+/-17.4 [standard deviation] vs 54.7+/-19.9; P=.71). Interobserver agreement was good for central lucencies and air bronchograms and poor to moderate for the other two findings (kappa<0.61). Compared with CT images without infarct, CT images with infarct had a higher frequency of vessel sign (32% [16 of 50] vs 11% [11 of 100], P=.029) and central lucencies (46% [23 of 50] vs 2% [two of 100], P<.001) and a lower frequency of air bronchograms (8% [four of 50] vs 40% [40 of 100], P=.003). Frequency of triangular shape was similar in both groups (52% [26 of 50] vs 40% [40 of 100], P=.17). Positive LR was 23.0 for central lucencies, 2.9 for vessel sign, 1.3 for triangular shape, and 0.2 for air bronchograms. Presence of central lucencies had 98% specificity and 46% sensitivity for pulmonary infarction. When the vessel sign and negative air bronchogram were combined with central lucencies, specificity increased to 99% but sensitivity decreased to 14%.
Central lucencies in peripheral consolidations are highly suggestive of pulmonary infarction.
回顾性确定在多排螺旋计算机断层扫描(CT)图像上,四种表现对于鉴别肺梗死与其他导致外周肺实变的病因的敏感性和特异性,并将其他CT表现及临床发现作为参考。
机构审查委员会批准了本研究并豁免了知情同意。三名独立放射科医生对50例肺梗死(未显示肺栓塞的直接动脉征)及100例其他病因所致外周实变的选定多层面CT图像进行了盲法分析。阅片者分析了四种表现:三角形形态、血管征(定义为实变顶点处存在增粗血管)、中央透亮区及空气支气管征。评估了观察者间一致性、有或无梗死的CT图像上的出现频率,以及每种表现对于肺梗死诊断的敏感性、特异性和阳性似然比(LR)。
对134例患者(75例男性,59例女性)的150处外周实变进行了分析(平均年龄,55.9岁±17.4[标准差]对54.7±19.9;P = 0.71)。观察者间对中央透亮区和空气支气管征的一致性良好,对其他两种表现的一致性为差至中等(kappa<0.61)。与无梗死的CT图像相比,有梗死的CT图像血管征(32%[50例中的16例]对11%[100例中的11例],P = 0.029)和中央透亮区(46%[50例中的23例]对2%[100例中的2例],P<0.001)的出现频率更高,空气支气管征的出现频率更低(8%[50例中的4例]对40%[100例中的40例],P = 0.003)。两组三角形形态的出现频率相似(52%[50例中的26例]对40%[100例中的40例],P = 0.17)。中央透亮区的阳性似然比为23.0,血管征为2.9,三角形形态为1.3,空气支气管征为0.2。中央透亮区对于肺梗死的特异性为98%,敏感性为46%。当血管征和空气支气管征阴性与中央透亮区相结合时,特异性增至99%,但敏感性降至14%。
外周实变中的中央透亮区高度提示肺梗死。