Leeprasert Wirat, Kaojarern Sming
Department of Medicine, Udonthani Hospital, Udonthani, Thailand.
J Med Assoc Thai. 2007 Jul;90(7):1467-76.
Bungarus candidus (Malayan krait) snake is a neurotoxin snake. Previous treatment after snakebite was mainly respiratory support until the patient had spontaneous breathing. Recently specific antivenom for the Bungarus candidus snake was produced by the Queen Saovabha Memorial Institute and distributed in June 2004. The present article is the first report on the clinical response to the specific antivenom for Bungarus candidus.
To analyze the signs and symptoms of patients after snakebite and the response of the patients after receiving specific antivenom for Bungarus candidus snake.
Retrospective chart review.
Four cases of Bungarus candidus snakebite were identified and divided into two groups. Group I (Case 1, 2, and 3) had received specific antivenom for Bungarus candidus while group 2 (case 4) had not. Onset, signs and symptoms after snakebite, antivenom dosage, and response time after receiving antivenom were analyzed.
The first three patients received specific antivenom for Bungarus candidus and the fourth patient did not receive any. All four patients developed neurological signs and symptoms from this neurotoxic venom. In case 1, 2, and 4, the first signs and symptoms were dyspnea, difficulty with speech, and opening the eyelids at 50 minutes (30-60 minutes). The onset ofother signs and symptoms included respiratory paralysis with intubation 3 hours (2-4 hours), full ptosis 3.66 hours (3-4 hours), mydriasis and fixedpupils 4.33 hours (4-5 hours), no response to stimuli 5.66 hours (4-10 hours), tachycardia 5.5 hours (47 hours), and hypertension 14 hours (4-24 hours). The first two patients received specific antivenom for Bungarus candidus after being bitten at 10 and 12 hours, respectively. The first clinical response in case 1, were 12 hours after receiving 16 vials, and in case 2, were 20 hours after receiving 16 vials. These were slight movement of feet phalanxes. At 40 hours after receiving specific antivenom 30 vials in case 1 and 32 vials in case 2, they were able to respond to commands, motor power changed from grade 0 to grade 1 and there was 50% elevated eyebrows. The motor power changedfrom grade I to grade 4 with 100% elevation of eyebrows from full ptosis was 65 hours after receiving specific antivenom 60 vials in case 1 and 70 hours after receiving specific antivenom 87 vials in case 2. The patients had spontaneous opening ofeyelids at 90 hours after receiving 80 vials for case I and 88 hours after receiving 87 vials for case 2. Case 2 was extubated on day 4 after the snakebite while case 1 was extubated later on day 10 because of superimposing pneumonia. The third case had delayed onset of signs and symptoms of neurotoxicity compared to the other three patients. Dyspnea, difficulty with speech, and opening eyelids occurred at 5 hours after the snakebite. No response to stimuli and respiratory paralysis occurred at 20 hours after the snakebite. His consciousness improved 10 hours after receiving 3 vials of specific antivenom. This was noted by being able to respond to commands and the motor power changed to grade 2 however, full ptosis was still present up to 24 hours. After receiving 23 vials ofspecific antivenom, he accidentally extubated himself however, he could breathe adequately using a mask with a bag. His motor power changed to grade 4 with 100% elevated eyebrows but full ptosis 34 hours after receiving 38 vials of specific antivenom. He could spontaneously open his eyelids 40 hours after receiving 38 vials specific antivenom. Cases 1, 2, and 3 had persistent mydriasis andfixed pupils until discharge. Case 4 did not receive specific antivenom for Bungarus candidus. He did not respond to stimuli 10 hours after snakebite and he was treated with respirator and symptomatic treatment. On day 2, his blood pressure dropped, he was on dopamine to raise his BP On day 3, he developed ventricular fibrillation. Defibrillation was administered and ECG returned to normal. He was given further supportive care. On day 7, he was discharged at the request of his relatives without any improvement.
The patients who received specific antivenom had more rapid improvement ofsigns and symptoms comparing to the patient who did not receive the antivenon.
马来环蛇是一种神经毒素毒蛇。以往蛇咬伤后的治疗主要是呼吸支持,直至患者自主呼吸恢复。最近,诗丽吉王后纪念研究所研制出了马来环蛇特异性抗蛇毒血清,并于2004年6月投入使用。本文是关于马来环蛇特异性抗蛇毒血清临床反应的首篇报道。
分析蛇咬伤患者的体征和症状,以及接受马来环蛇特异性抗蛇毒血清治疗后患者的反应。
回顾性病历审查。
确定4例马来环蛇咬伤病例并分为两组。第一组(病例1、2和3)接受了马来环蛇特异性抗蛇毒血清治疗,而第二组(病例4)未接受治疗。分析了蛇咬伤后的发病时间、体征和症状、抗蛇毒血清剂量以及接受抗蛇毒血清后的反应时间。
前三例患者接受了马来环蛇特异性抗蛇毒血清治疗,第四例患者未接受任何治疗。所有4例患者均因这种神经毒性毒液出现了神经体征和症状。在病例1、2和4中,最初的体征和症状是呼吸困难、言语困难,在50分钟(30 - 60分钟)时睁眼困难。其他体征和症状的出现时间包括:3小时(2 - 4小时)出现呼吸麻痹并插管,3.66小时(3 - 4小时)完全上睑下垂,4.33小时(4 - 5小时)瞳孔散大且固定,5.66小时(4 - 10小时)对刺激无反应,5.5小时(4 - 7小时)心动过速,14小时(4 - 24小时)高血压。前两例患者分别在被咬伤10小时和12小时后接受了马来环蛇特异性抗蛇毒血清治疗。病例1在接受16瓶抗蛇毒血清后的首次临床反应是12小时后出现,病例2在接受16瓶抗蛇毒血清后的首次临床反应是20小时后出现,表现为脚趾轻微活动。病例1在接受30瓶特异性抗蛇毒血清、病例2在接受32瓶特异性抗蛇毒血清40小时后,能够对指令做出反应,肌力从0级变为1级,眉毛抬高50%。病例1在接受60瓶特异性抗蛇毒血清65小时后、病例2在接受87瓶特异性抗蛇毒血清70小时后,肌力从1级变为4级,眉毛从完全下垂状态抬高100%。病例1在接受80瓶抗蛇毒血清90小时后、病例2在接受87瓶抗蛇毒血清88小时后能够自主睁眼。病例2在蛇咬伤后第4天拔管,病例1因并发肺炎在第10天晚些时候拔管。与其他三名患者相比,第三例患者神经毒性体征和症状的出现时间较晚。蛇咬伤后5小时出现呼吸困难、言语困难和睁眼困难。蛇咬伤后20小时出现对刺激无反应和呼吸麻痹。他在接受3瓶特异性抗蛇毒血清10小时后意识有所改善,表现为能够对指令做出反应,肌力变为2级,但直至24小时仍完全上睑下垂。在接受23瓶特异性抗蛇毒血清后,他意外自行拔管,但使用带储气囊面罩能充分呼吸。在接受38瓶特异性抗蛇毒血清34小时后,他的肌力变为4级,眉毛抬高100%,但仍完全上睑下垂。在接受38瓶特异性抗蛇毒血清40小时后能够自主睁眼。病例1、2和3直至出院时瞳孔一直散大且固定。病例4未接受马来环蛇特异性抗蛇毒血清治疗。他在蛇咬伤10小时后对刺激无反应,接受了呼吸机和对症治疗。第2天,他血压下降,使用多巴胺提升血压。第3天,他发生室颤,进行了除颤,心电图恢复正常。给予了进一步的支持治疗。第7天,应其亲属要求出院,无任何改善。
与未接受抗蛇毒血清治疗的患者相比,接受特异性抗蛇毒血清治疗的患者体征和症状改善更快。