Haas Alex Nogueira, Silveira Elcia Maria Varize, Rösing Cassiano Kuchenbecker
Department of Periodontology, Federal University of Rio Grande do Sul, Porto Alegre, RS, Brazil.
Oral Health Prev Dent. 2007;5(2):89-94.
The aim of this randomised single-blind, cross-over trial was to assess the effect of tongue cleansing on morning oral malodour in periodontally healthy subjects.
Ten systemically healthy non-smoker subjects (6 males, 4 females), 24-38 years of age, completed two 4-day periods of oral hygiene cessation with a 7-day wash-out period. In one of these test periods, subjects were instructed to clean their tongues with a tongue scraper 2-3 times a day. Participants presented at least 20 teeth, without cavities, overhanging restorations/prostheses or periodontitis, and had no history of previous periodontal therapy or use of antibiotics in the 3 months prior to the study. Volatile sulphur compounds (VSC; Interscan Halimeter) and organoleptic scores were measured in exhaled mouth air once a day, early in the morning, by one examiner. Comparisons were performed using Wilcoxon's signed rank test and Friedman's test (alpha = 0.05).
VSC levels at baseline were 206.3 ppb (SD 139.8) and 191.4 ppb (SD 127.7) for periods of usage and non-usage of the scraper respectively (p > 0.05). VSC levels did not change significantly during the 4 days, independent of tongue cleansing (Friedman, p > 0.05). Only at day 3 did the use of the tongue scraper lead to a significantly lower level of VSC compared with controls (131.1 ppb and 199.3 ppb respectively). No significant differences in organoleptic scores were observed between groups at baseline. During the whole experimental period, there were also no significant changes in organoleptic scores when individuals used or did not use the tongue scraper.
Tongue cleansing with a scraper was unable to prevent morning oral malodour in the absence of tooth cleaning in periodontally healthy individuals.
本随机单盲交叉试验旨在评估舌清洁对牙周健康受试者晨起口腔异味的影响。
10名全身健康的非吸烟受试者(6名男性,4名女性),年龄在24至38岁之间,完成了两个为期4天的口腔卫生停止期,中间有7天的洗脱期。在其中一个测试期,受试者被指示每天用舌刷清洁舌头2至3次。参与者至少有20颗牙齿,无龋齿、悬突修复体/假牙或牙周炎,且在研究前3个月内无牙周治疗史或抗生素使用史。由一名检查者每天清晨在呼出的口腔气体中测量挥发性硫化物(VSC;Interscan Halimeter)和感官评分。使用Wilcoxon符号秩检验和Friedman检验进行比较(α = 0.05)。
使用和不使用舌刷期间,基线时的VSC水平分别为206.3 ppb(标准差139.8)和191.4 ppb(标准差127.7)(p > 0.05)。在4天内,VSC水平没有显著变化,与舌清洁无关(Friedman检验,p > 0.05)。仅在第3天,与对照组相比,使用舌刷导致VSC水平显著降低(分别为131.1 ppb和199.3 ppb)。基线时两组之间的感官评分没有显著差异。在整个实验期间,个体使用或不使用舌刷时,感官评分也没有显著变化。
在牙周健康个体中,在不进行牙齿清洁的情况下,用舌刷清洁舌头无法预防晨起口腔异味。