Willan Andrew R, Kowgier Matthew E
Program in Child Health Evaluative Sciences, CHES, SickKids Research Institute, Toronto, Ont., Canada.
Health Econ. 2008 Jul;17(7):777-91. doi: 10.1002/hec.1289.
In a recent multinational randomized clinical trial, 1356 patients from 14 countries were randomized between two arms. The primary measure of effectiveness was 30-day survival. Health care utilization was collected on all patients and was combined with a single country's price weights to provide patient-level cost data. The purpose of this paper is to report the results of the cost-effectiveness analysis for the country that provided the cost weights, so as to provide a case study for illustrating recently proposed methodologies that account for skewed cost data, the between-country variation in treatment effects, possible interactions between treatment and baseline covariates, and the difficulty of estimated adjusted risk differences. A hierarchal model is used to account for the two sources of variation (between country and between patients, within a country). The model, which uses gamma distributions for cost data and recent methods for estimating adjusted risk differences, provides overall and country-specific estimates of treatment effects. Model estimation is facilitated by Markov chain Monte Carlo methods using the WinBUGS software. In addition, the theory of expected value of information is used to determine if the data provided by the trial are sufficient for decision making.
在最近一项多国随机临床试验中,来自14个国家的1356名患者被随机分为两组。有效性的主要衡量指标是30天生存率。收集了所有患者的医疗保健利用率,并将其与一个国家的价格权重相结合,以提供患者层面的成本数据。本文的目的是报告提供成本权重的国家的成本效益分析结果,以便提供一个案例研究,来说明最近提出的方法,这些方法考虑了成本数据的偏态、治疗效果的国家间差异、治疗与基线协变量之间可能的相互作用,以及估计调整后风险差异的难度。使用层次模型来考虑两种变异来源(国家间和国家内患者间)。该模型使用伽马分布处理成本数据,并采用最近的方法估计调整后的风险差异,提供治疗效果的总体和特定国家估计值。使用WinBUGS软件的马尔可夫链蒙特卡罗方法有助于模型估计。此外,信息期望值理论用于确定试验提供的数据是否足以用于决策。