Dinndorf Patricia Anne, Gootenberg Joseph, Cohen Martin H, Keegan Patricia, Pazdur Richard
U.S. Food and Drug Administration, White Oak Campus, 10903 New Hampshire Avenue, Building 22, Room 2102, Silver Spring, Maryland 20993-0002, USA.
Oncologist. 2007 Aug;12(8):991-8. doi: 10.1634/theoncologist.12-8-991.
On July 24, 2006, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration granted approval to pegaspargase (Oncaspar; Enzon Pharmaceuticals, Inc., Bridgewater, NJ; hereafter, O) for the first-line treatment of patients with acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL) as a component of a multiagent chemotherapy regimen. O was previously approved in February 1994 for the treatment of patients with ALL who were hypersensitive to native forms of L-asparaginase. The trial supporting this new indication was an open label, randomized, multicenter clinical trial that enrolled 118 children (age, 1-9 years) with previously untreated, standard risk ALL. Patients received either native Escherichia coli asparaginase (Elspar; Merck, Whitehouse Station, NJ; hereafter, E) or O along with multiagent chemotherapy during remission induction and delayed intensification (DI) phases of treatment. O, at a dose of 2,500 IU/m(2), was administered i.m. on day 3 of the 4-week induction phase and on day 3 of each of two 8-week DI phases. E, at a dose of 6,000 IU/m(2), was administered i.m. three times weekly for nine doses during induction and for six doses during each DI phase. This study allowed direct comparison of O and E for asparagine depletion, asparaginase activity, and development of asparaginase antibodies. An unplanned comparison of event-free survival (EFS) was conducted to rule out a deleterious O efficacy effect. Following induction and DI treatment there was complete (</=1 microM) or moderate (1-10 microM) depletion of serum asparagine levels in the large majority of samples tested over the 4-week period in both O-treated and E-treated subjects. Similarly, depletion of cerebrospinal fluid asparagine levels during induction was similar between O-treated and E-treated subjects. The number of days asparaginase activity exceeded >0.03 IU/ml in O-treated subjects was greater than the number of days in E-treated subjects during both the induction and DI phases of treatment. There was no correlation, however, between asparaginase activity and serum asparagine levels, making the former determination less clinically relevant. Using the protocol-prespecified threshold for a positive result of >2.5 times the control, 7 of 56 (12%) O subjects tested at any time during the study demonstrated antiasparaginase antibodies and 16 of 57 (28%) E subjects tested at any time during the study had antiasparaginase antibodies. In both study arms EFS was in the range of 80% at 3 years. The most serious, sometimes fatal, O toxicities were anaphylaxis, other serious allergic reactions, thrombosis (including sagittal sinus thrombosis), pancreatitis, glucose intolerance, and coagulopathy. The most common adverse events were allergic reactions (including anaphylaxis), hyperglycemia, pancreatitis, central nervous system thrombosis, coagulopathy, hyperbilirubinemia, and elevated transaminases. Disclosure of potential conflicts of interest is found at the end of this article.
2006年7月24日,美国食品药品监督管理局批准聚乙二醇天冬酰胺酶(Oncaspar;Enzon制药公司,新泽西州布里奇沃特市;以下简称O)作为多药化疗方案的一部分,用于急性淋巴细胞白血病(ALL)患者的一线治疗。O于1994年2月首次获批,用于治疗对天然形式的L-天冬酰胺酶过敏的ALL患者。支持这一新适应症的试验是一项开放标签、随机、多中心临床试验,纳入了118名年龄在1至9岁、先前未接受治疗的低危ALL儿童。患者在缓解诱导期和延迟强化期(DI)接受天然大肠杆菌天冬酰胺酶(Elspar;默克公司,新泽西州白宫站;以下简称E)或O联合多药化疗。O的剂量为2500 IU/m²,在4周诱导期的第3天以及两个8周DI期的每个第3天进行肌肉注射。E的剂量为6000 IU/m²,在诱导期每周肌肉注射3次,共9剂,在每个DI期注射6剂。本研究允许直接比较O和E在天冬酰胺消耗、天冬酰胺酶活性以及天冬酰胺酶抗体产生方面的情况。进行了无事件生存期(EFS)的非计划比较,以排除O疗效的有害影响。在诱导期和DI期治疗后,在O治疗组和E治疗组受试者中,在4周期间测试的大多数样本中,血清天冬酰胺水平出现了完全(≤1微摩尔)或中度(1至10微摩尔)降低。同样,在诱导期,O治疗组和E治疗组受试者脑脊液中天冬酰胺水平的降低情况相似。在治疗的诱导期和DI期,O治疗组受试者中天冬酰胺酶活性超过0.03 IU/ml的天数均多于E治疗组受试者。然而,天冬酰胺酶活性与血清天冬酰胺水平之间没有相关性,这使得前者的测定在临床上相关性较低。使用方案预先规定的阳性结果阈值(>对照值的2.5倍),在研究期间任何时间进行测试的56名O组受试者中有7名(12%)出现抗天冬酰胺酶抗体,57名E组受试者中有16名(28%)在研究期间任何时间进行测试时有抗天冬酰胺酶抗体。在两个研究组中,3年时的EFS均在80%左右。O最严重的毒性反应(有时是致命的)包括过敏反应、其他严重过敏反应、血栓形成(包括矢状窦血栓形成)、胰腺炎、葡萄糖不耐受和凝血病。最常见的不良事件是过敏反应(包括过敏)、高血糖、胰腺炎、中枢神经系统血栓形成、凝血病、高胆红素血症和转氨酶升高。潜在利益冲突的披露见本文末尾。