González-Castaño D, Pena J, Sánchez-Doblado F, Hartmann G H, Gómez F, Leal A
Departamento de Física de Partículas, Universidad de Santiago de Compostela, Santiago de Compostela, Spain.
Med Biol Eng Comput. 2008 Apr;46(4):373-80. doi: 10.1007/s11517-007-0249-z. Epub 2007 Sep 8.
Significant deviations from the expected dose have been reported in the absolute dosimetry validation of an intensity modulated radiation therapy treatment when individual segments are analyzed. However, when full treatment is considered and all segment doses are added together, these discrepancies fade out, leading to overall dose deviations below a 5% action level. This contradictory behavior may be caused by a partial compensation between detector over-responding and under-responding for measurement conditions far from radiation equilibrium. We consider three treatment verification scenarios that may lead to ionization chamber miss-responding, namely: narrow beam irradiation, field penumbra location and multi-leaf collimator transmission contribution. In this work we have analyzed the response of three different ionization chambers with different active volume under these conditions by means of Monte Carlo (MC) simulation methods. Correction factors needed to convert the detector readout into actual dose to water were calculated by inserting the specific detector geometry (carefully modeled) into the simulations. This procedure required extensive use of parallel computing resources in order to achieve the desired level of uncertainty in the final results. The analysis of the simulations shows the relative contribution of each of the three previously mentioned miss-responding scenarios. Additionally, we provide some evidence on dose deviation compensation in multi-segment radiotherapy treatment verification.
在对调强放射治疗的绝对剂量测定验证中,当分析单个射野时,已报告出现与预期剂量的显著偏差。然而,当考虑整个治疗过程并将所有射野剂量相加时,这些差异就会消失,导致总体剂量偏差低于5%的行动水平。这种矛盾的行为可能是由于在远离辐射平衡的测量条件下,探测器的过度响应和响应不足之间存在部分补偿。我们考虑了三种可能导致电离室响应错误的治疗验证情况,即:窄束照射、射野半影位置和多叶准直器透射贡献。在这项工作中,我们通过蒙特卡罗(MC)模拟方法分析了在这些条件下三种具有不同有效体积的不同电离室的响应。通过将特定的探测器几何结构(经过精确建模)插入模拟中,计算出将探测器读数转换为实际水吸收剂量所需的校正因子。为了在最终结果中达到所需的不确定度水平,该过程需要大量使用并行计算资源。模拟分析显示了上述三种响应错误情况各自的相对贡献。此外,我们提供了一些关于多射野放射治疗验证中剂量偏差补偿的证据。