Ohmori M
Japan Anti-Tuberculosis Association, Tokyo.
Kekkaku. 1991 Dec;66(12):819-28.
The time of eradication of tuberculosis has been discussed for several countries, and based on those results, a new strategic plan and goals have been elaborated. Considering such developments, and in order to make a new tuberculosis control strategy, it is important to determine the point at which eradication of tuberculosis would be achieved in Japan. Styblo proposed the two conventional definitions of eradication of tuberculosis, namely that the incidence of smear-positive tuberculosis has fallen below 1 per million population or that the prevalence of tuberculosis infection in the general population has fallen below 1% and continues to decrease. The bacteriological results of new cases have been reported since 1975 in Japan. However, those results are still of doubtful validity and reliability. Therefore, the author estimated the year of eradication of tuberculosis, according to the criterion that tuberculosis is eradicated when the proportion of the population infected with tubercle bacilli is less than 1%. If the risk of infection is changing at a regular rate, it is possible to estimate the risk of infection at any time in the past and in the future. Once the risk of infection is determined, it is also possible to calculate the age-specific prevalence of infection and the proportion of the population infected with tubercle bacilli at various times in the past and in the future. In Japan, the risk of infection before World War II was assumed to be around 4% and not to vary with calendar year. And based on the data from the prevalence surveys in Okinawa in 1968 and 1973, the risk of infection was estimated 0.3% in 1968 and has declined on average, by 10 to 11% annually. At that time, Okinawa was the only area free from BCG vaccination in Japan. The incidence rate in Japan also has declined, on average, by 10% annually. However, since late 1970s, the annual speed of decline of the incidence rate has been slowed down. Therefore, I assumed that the recent trend of the infection risk is the same as the trend of the recent incidence rate among the 0-29 year age-group. The size of the effect of age on the risk of infection has been discussed. The author also considered age-effects in the model. The weight applied to the risk of infection by age was determined by examining the age-specific positive rate in the 1930s before the era when BCG vaccination was widely used.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)
几个国家都已探讨过结核病消除的时间,并基于这些结果制定了新的战略计划和目标。考虑到这些进展,为制定新的结核病控制策略,确定日本实现结核病消除的时间点很重要。斯蒂布洛提出了结核病消除的两个传统定义,即涂片阳性结核病的发病率降至每百万人口1例以下,或普通人群中结核感染率降至1%以下并持续下降。自1975年以来日本已报告了新病例的细菌学结果。然而,这些结果的有效性和可靠性仍存疑问。因此,作者根据结核杆菌感染人群比例小于1%时结核病即被消除的标准,估算了结核病消除的年份。如果感染风险以固定速率变化,就有可能估算过去和未来任何时间的感染风险。一旦确定了感染风险,也能够计算特定年龄的感染患病率以及过去和未来不同时间结核杆菌感染人群的比例。在日本,二战前的感染风险假定约为4%,且不随历年变化。根据1968年和1973年冲绳县患病率调查的数据,1968年的感染风险估计为0.3%,且平均每年下降10%至11%。当时,冲绳县是日本唯一未进行卡介苗接种的地区。日本的发病率平均每年也下降10%。然而,自20世纪70年代末以来,发病率的年下降速度有所放缓。因此,作者假定近期感染风险趋势与0至29岁年龄组近期发病率趋势相同。年龄对感染风险的影响大小已得到讨论。作者在模型中也考虑了年龄效应。通过研究卡介苗广泛使用之前的20世纪30年代特定年龄的阳性率,确定了年龄对感染风险的加权。(摘要截选至400字)