Meese Tim S, Summers Robert J
School of Life and Health Sciences, Aston University, Birmingham B47ET, UK.
Proc Biol Sci. 2007 Nov 22;274(1627):2891-900. doi: 10.1098/rspb.2007.0957.
The initial image-processing stages of visual cortex are well suited to a local (patchwise) analysis of the viewed scene. But the world's structures extend over space as textures and surfaces, suggesting the need for spatial integration. Most models of contrast vision fall shy of this process because (i) the weak area summation at detection threshold is attributed to probability summation (PS) and (ii) there is little or no advantage of area well above threshold. Both of these views are challenged here. First, it is shown that results at threshold are consistent with linear summation of contrast following retinal inhomogeneity, spatial filtering, nonlinear contrast transduction and multiple sources of additive Gaussian noise. We suggest that the suprathreshold loss of the area advantage in previous studies is due to a concomitant increase in suppression from the pedestal. To overcome this confound, a novel stimulus class is designed where: (i) the observer operates on a constant retinal area, (ii) the target area is controlled within this summation field, and (iii) the pedestal is fixed in size. Using this arrangement, substantial summation is found along the entire masking function, including the region of facilitation. Our analysis shows that PS and uncertainty cannot account for the results, and that suprathreshold summation of contrast extends over at least seven target cycles of grating.
视觉皮层的初始图像处理阶段非常适合对所观察场景进行局部(逐块)分析。但是世界的结构以纹理和表面的形式在空间上延伸,这表明需要进行空间整合。大多数对比度视觉模型都未能达到这一过程,原因在于:(i)检测阈值处的弱区域总和被归因于概率总和(PS),以及(ii)在阈值以上的区域几乎没有优势。本文对这两种观点都提出了挑战。首先,研究表明阈值处的结果与视网膜不均匀性、空间滤波、非线性对比度转换以及加性高斯噪声的多个来源之后的对比度线性总和一致。我们认为,先前研究中阈值以上区域优势的丧失是由于来自背景的抑制作用同时增加。为了克服这一混淆因素,设计了一种新颖的刺激类别,其中:(i)观察者在恒定的视网膜区域上进行操作,(ii)目标区域在这个总和场中得到控制,并且(iii)背景的大小是固定的。采用这种设置,在整个掩蔽函数上都发现了显著的总和,包括易化区域。我们的分析表明,PS和不确定性无法解释这些结果,并且对比度的阈值以上总和至少延伸到七个光栅目标周期。