Tyson Sarah, Watson Anita, Moss Sylvia, Troop Hilary, Dean-Lofthouse Gill, Jorritsma Sjoerd, Shannon Michelle
Physiotherapy Directorate, University of Salford, UK.
Disabil Rehabil. 2008;30(2):142-9. doi: 10.1080/09638280701216847.
Neurological physiotherapists recognize the need to include standardized outcome measures (OMs) in clinical practice but lack of information about the OMs available hampers utilization. This paper reports on the first stage of a project to identify the most robust OMs for use in neurological physiotherapy.
To identify what physiotherapists perceive that they need to measure during a neurological assessment.
Three separate workshops were held using patient vignettes to represent the acute, rehabilitation and community settings. Thirty senior neurological physiotherapists participated and were asked: 'What would you observe, test or measure if assessing this patient?' Data were analysed using thematic content analysis performed independently by each of the authors. Internal and external member checking ensured validity. In addition, the authors produced definitions of the items and domains identified in the data collection and subsequent content analysis.
Items from the data collection were classified into 16 domains that physiotherapists need to measure: Weakness; range of movement/contracture; pain; muscle tone/spasticity; sensation; ataxia/co-ordination; personal fatigue; oedema; subluxation; postural and balance impairment; walking impairment; upper limb; balance disability; walking disability; mobility disability and falls.
The domains that physiotherapists need to measure during clinical assessment were identified. In the second stage of the project these domains will inform systematic reviews to identify the most robust outcome measures for use in clinical practice.
神经物理治疗师认识到在临床实践中纳入标准化结局指标(OMs)的必要性,但缺乏关于现有OMs的信息阻碍了其应用。本文报告了一个项目的第一阶段,该项目旨在确定神经物理治疗中最可靠的OMs。
确定物理治疗师认为在神经评估过程中需要测量的内容。
举办了三场独立的研讨会,使用患者案例来代表急性、康复和社区环境。30名资深神经物理治疗师参与其中,并被问及:“如果评估该患者,你会观察、测试或测量什么?”数据由每位作者独立进行主题内容分析。内部和外部成员核查确保了有效性。此外,作者对数据收集及后续内容分析中确定的项目和领域进行了定义。
数据收集的项目被归类为物理治疗师需要测量的16个领域:虚弱;活动范围/挛缩;疼痛;肌张力/痉挛;感觉;共济失调/协调能力;个人疲劳;水肿;半脱位;姿势和平衡障碍;步行障碍;上肢;平衡残疾;步行残疾;活动能力残疾和跌倒。
确定了物理治疗师在临床评估中需要测量的领域。在项目的第二阶段,这些领域将为系统评价提供信息,以确定临床实践中最可靠的结局指标。