Muslimovic D, Post B, Speelman J D, Schmand B
Department of Neurology, Academic Medical Centre, Amsterdam, The Netherlands.
Brain. 2007 Nov;130(Pt 11):2887-97. doi: 10.1093/brain/awm211. Epub 2007 Sep 13.
Functional neuroimaging research has repeatedly implicated the striatum in motor procedural learning, but attempts to explore this relation in patients with Parkinson's disease (PD) have yielded inconsistent results. Furthermore, the functional impact of procedural learning impairment is unknown. The present study sought to examine the effects of PD on procedural learning and to determine whether impaired procedural learning affects functional status. The performance of 95 non-demented PD patients on the serial reaction time task (SRTT) was compared with that of 44 demographically matched control subjects. The SRTT is a four-choice reaction time task in which visual stimuli are presented in six blocks of 100 trials either in a repeating sequence of 10 stimuli or randomly. Learning was inferred from the reduction of response times over five successive blocks of repeating sequence trials and from the increase in response times in the sixth random block. In addition, neuropsychological tests of declarative memory, executive and visuospatial functions were administered to all participants. Patients also received quantitative ratings of functional outcome. The two groups did not differ in the learning rate across blocks of repeating sequence trials. However, PD patients were significantly less efficient than controls in acquiring sequence-specific knowledge, although this impairment was relatively small (d = 0.38). Patients with more advanced clinical symptoms tended to show worse performance. Separate analyses of a subgroup of 24 non-medicated patients in the early stages of PD revealed no differences in SRTT performance relative to controls. Neuropsychological testing showed impairments in attention and executive functions, immediate and delayed explicit memory and visuospatial skills in the PD group, but none of the cognitive measures were related to procedural learning. Reduced motor sequence learning in PD patients did not influence their functional status. These findings indicate that procedural learning impairment is not an early feature of PD, but is likely to emerge with progression of the disease, independently of cognitive dysfunction or dopaminergic medication.
功能性神经影像学研究反复表明纹状体与运动程序性学习有关,但在帕金森病(PD)患者中探索这种关系的尝试却产生了不一致的结果。此外,程序性学习障碍的功能影响尚不清楚。本研究旨在探讨PD对程序性学习的影响,并确定程序性学习受损是否会影响功能状态。将95名非痴呆PD患者在序列反应时任务(SRTT)上的表现与44名人口统计学匹配的对照受试者进行比较。SRTT是一项四选一的反应时任务,视觉刺激以10个刺激的重复序列或随机方式呈现,共六个100次试验的块。从连续五个重复序列试验块中反应时间的减少以及第六个随机块中反应时间的增加推断学习情况。此外,对所有参与者进行了陈述性记忆、执行和视觉空间功能的神经心理学测试。患者还接受了功能结局的定量评分。两组在重复序列试验块的学习率上没有差异。然而,PD患者在获取序列特异性知识方面的效率明显低于对照组,尽管这种损害相对较小(d = 0.38)。临床症状较严重的患者往往表现更差。对24名处于PD早期的未用药患者亚组进行的单独分析显示,其SRTT表现与对照组相比没有差异。神经心理学测试表明,PD组在注意力和执行功能、即时和延迟的显性记忆以及视觉空间技能方面存在损害,但没有一项认知测量与程序性学习相关。PD患者运动序列学习的减少并未影响其功能状态。这些发现表明,程序性学习障碍不是PD的早期特征,而是可能随着疾病进展而出现,与认知功能障碍或多巴胺能药物无关。